Ref4Me

Recent content by Redster

  1. R

    What can't players shout?

    He was too apologetic and it was too funny. I couldn't stay mad. Believe me, I tried.
  2. R

    What can't players shout?

    I had one on the weekend - striker beats defender who, when striker is 8 yards from goal, screams at him. Striker fluffs kick and GK collects the scraps. Whistle, IFK, yellow. All accepted with little question. Couldn't bring myself to DOGSO as the striker seemed to be off balance anyway.
  3. R

    Penalty kick or not?

    Yeh, I think we can limit our disagreement to seeing this particular event differently.
  4. R

    Sporting Lisbon x Gil Vicente

    @Murri O But for @one 's helpful still (which seems to indicate this should be a FK to the keeper), I'd go penalty on this one Assuming he is not in control and he has merely patted the ball away, careless charge regardless of whether he's tipped the ball away or not. Could have avoided the...
  5. R

    Penalty kick or not?

    This is now rather hypothetical. The OP GK did not dive headlong into another player. His movement was across the path of the striker and not towards him. If anything, the striker has run into the GK. For me, if the GK is doing something they would be expected to do, we should be cautious...
  6. R

    Penalty kick or not?

    Trips are only offences if careless, of course. And it's different because he's not tapping past, he is shooting. The GK is making a save. They are conceptually distinct. It's readily accepted that sometimes saves are not successful. It's also readily accepted, I would suggest, that if an...
  7. R

    Penalty kick or not?

    Then what is the offence?
  8. R

    Penalty kick or not?

    Why do you say it is careless? What has the goalkeeper been careless as to?
  9. R

    Penalty kick or not?

    It's not mistimed. Nor is it careless The striker is the one who has run into the keeper. Players are entitled to their position
  10. R

    Penalty kick or not?

    I dispute that he gets taken late. His forward momentum takes him over the GK who is diving to make a save. The GK does not lunge or jump at him
  11. R

    Penalty kick or not?

    It's an attempted save where the striker runs over the goalkeeper.
  12. R

    What can't players shout?

    Yeh, flag and secret squirrel signal for caution
  13. R

    Grassroots Penalty?

    Doesn't make the offence at 21.11 any more red...
  14. R

    What can't players shout?

    I was AR on a match recently where I flagged because a player near me coming in to challenge for a high ball barked like a dog so loudly the opponent under the ball took his eyes off and turned around.
  15. R

    worthy of a red?

    But you're still applying objective criteria and using the reaction if the player as evidence of the degree of offinabus. I take it @RyantheRef is urging caution against allowing emotions affect decisions because the decision could be less affected by the temperature of the match and more by...
Top