The Ref Stop

Recent content by DJIC

  1. D

    Rugby Union Red cards

    After the Japan 40 second RC yesterday. Anyone think the 20 minute red card for a technical/accidental RC, would work in football. Our technical red cards DOGSO, maybe 2nd YC, accidental SFP, if there is such a thing? Rugby Union: The 20-Minute Red Card (Technical / Accidental) Offenses...
  2. D

    Sunderland v Chelsea

    I agree, foul to the defensive team for initial shirt pull which ended in the foul on the attacker. However RefWatch (Dermot, Bothroyd, Shewood) all agreed a clear penalty?!?!
  3. D

    Arsenal Vs Hull

    Also both Keith Hackett & Mike Dean both originally stated offside was the correct call, only to reflect & change their minds. So surprisingly we have MO, KH & MD all incorrect in law.
  4. D

    New LoTG - Injuries - Liking it!!

    Could the law be amended? Player has to leave pitch for 1 min, unless the referee decides a careless foul has caused the player to require immediate treatment. It just seems to me unfair that a fouled player is penalised, whereas the offender’s team benefits. It is subjective but the losing...
  5. D

    Arsenal Vs Hull

    I agree, very strange, even at my grass roots level of knowledge, having seen this play out in a Newcastle match last season, foul comes before offside. Regardless, to restart with offside seems incorrect, if there is no shirt pull then he hasn't committed an offside offence. I think the law...
  6. D

    Penalty - Completed "runup"?

    I think ‘bizarre’ covers it blowing the whistle as the player is putting the ball on the penalty spot, has caused his issue.
  7. D

    New LoTG - Injuries - Liking it!!

    Law states a ‘running clock’ so presume ball out of play still counts within the one minute. ‘The one minute is timed using a running clock and is determined by the referee, who may be assisted by the other match officials.’
  8. D

    Boca v Riverplate

    Red card understood, but not a single YC for surrounding the referee? How many would you have issued?
  9. D

    Man C v BHA - backpass claim

    I’m sort of ok, not being a back pass, the defender had no other option than to intercept the ball the way he did. Haaland behind him, it wasn’t a conscious decision to pass the ball to the GK but an interception. I agree a corner kick instead of a IDFK makes sense in law for this offence.
  10. D

    Oldham v Crawley Town - Two 1H Red Cards

    A couple of reds here which caused significant debate and crowd abuse to referee David Rock. https://www.skysports.com/football/oldham-athletic-vs-crawley-town/5091374016586546232 (play with sound down!) PS. He does issue cards, his four League 2 matches in October, 30 YCs & 2 RCs.
  11. D

    Double touch penalty

    For completeness 😂 the kicker accidentally kicks the ball with both feet simultaneously or the ball touches their non-kicking foot or leg immediately after the kick: if the ball enters the goal from the kick, the kick is retaken if the ball does not enter the goal from the kick, an indirect...
  12. D

    Fleetwood v Arsenal

  13. D

    Double touch penalty

    Good reminder that the double touch penalty is now a retake.
  14. D

    Fleetwood v Arsenal

    That’s always my last thought in the process, do I have any option/reasoning to keep the player on the pitch?
  15. D

    Spurs v Arsenal WSL hand ball

    We have spoken about players having their hands in a natural position if somebody is going to kick the ball at them from close range. Going away from goal a factor too, why would you make your body bigger? Thoughts? https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/videos/cw62ylp68m4po
Back
Top