A&H

David G's latest activity

  • D
    David G replied to the thread Promotions - Season Ending 2024.
    I agree with you on this one. I am not sure what else he would expect.
  • D
    David G reacted to Runner Ref's post in the thread Promotions - Season Ending 2024 with Like Like.
    As much as I think things could be improved, of course the tables are based on subjective interpretations. Unless you're marking a maths...
  • D
    David G reacted to Big Cat's post in the thread Promotions - Season Ending 2024 with Like Like.
    Well done to that Referee
  • D
    David G replied to the thread VAR Vote.
    I think you want to create argument. VAR/Anthony Taylor didn’t consider it to be handball. The KMI panel didn’t consider it to be...
  • D
    David G replied to the thread Promotions - Season Ending 2024.
    I’ve just received a phone call from a Referee informing me he has been promoted to Specialist Assistant on the National League - Prem...
  • D
    David G replied to the thread VAR Vote.
    Of course they have a clue with regarding handball, which is why AT & SA were correct not to award a penalty against Ashley Young.
  • D
    David G replied to the thread VAR Vote.
    I am happy to disagree with any official when I believe it’s due and to be constructive with it - for me, criticism is not a word I like...
  • D
    David G replied to the thread VAR Vote.
    Perhaps, though could also be argued that all games are Refereed differently, depending upon who the Referee is, the circumstances of...
  • D
    David G replied to the thread VAR Vote.
    That is something that some would say is appropriate & some like Keith Hackett would say to have ex Refs, though I think it’s...
  • D
    David G replied to the thread VAR Vote.
    Well you couldn’t have all Referees or ex Referees judging VAR decisions for obvious reasons, so it has to be a panel of those who...
  • D
    David G replied to the thread VAR Vote.
    We know who makes the decisions to create the stat - The Independent Key Match Incident Panel that consists of 5 members viz 3 ex...
  • D
    David G replied to the thread VAR Vote.
    A few are still being missed, but stats say only a maximum of 4%. If VAR passes the 6th June vote by clubs I reckon that will get down...
  • D
    David G replied to the thread VAR Vote.
    That’s a fair reflection of my thinking though there has to be something in place to avoid the Maradona hand of god type incidents. They...
  • D
    David G replied to the thread VAR Vote.
    Maradona hand of god which is why VAR was conceived in the first place and VAR has gone much beyond that (probably to justify the cost...
  • D
    David G replied to the thread VAR Vote.
    Football didn’t altogether ignore, but had different challenges, whereas, whilst predominantly VAR is suited to rugby and cricket...
Show older items
Back
Top