So at the weekend green v red. Red is running down the wing and cuts inside to go in the box. He knocks it past the defender and goes to run around him by running off the pitch. The defender spots this and takes a step off the pitch to make it harder for the attacker to get around. As the red tries to get back on the green defender pushes him. Now I blow for a free kick and bottle it a bit and say it's a free kick on the edge of the box. Now had they been on the pitch I think they just about would have been inside the penalty area. Should this still be a pen even if they aren't on the pitch?