Why don't you read the law first and then ask on here if you're still unsure? You need to understand the law BEFORE you go out there on the pitch and if you did, you'd know the distinction between DOGSO red and DOGSO yellow.Was i wrong in law for giving the pen and a red card?
I did know there Was a law change but didn't know 100% What exactly the change wasSounds like you didn’t have a clue about the law change, if you did then you might have known where the manager was coming from.
I did know there Was a law change but didn't know 100% What exactly the change was
Did you thank @Padfoot for his wisdom?? He has feelings too!!!You were unsure and therefore asked the question on here which is the right thing to do in the circumstances.
No, it most definitely does not. All kinds of wrong decisions can be made - the mere fact that they were made does not mean they were right.Does the fact that the attacker is dismissed for DOGSO not give you the answer to your question?
Admittedly, a tackle from behind means it's probably less likely to be an attempt to play the ball but I've seen plenty of tackles from behind that were attempts to play the ball. Illegal attempts perhaps, but attempts nonetheless.PS I doubt it, considering the tackle as the OP stated was from behind
The word 'genuine' was never in the main wording of the law to start with. It was however, included in the explanation given in the 'Details of Law changes' section when the change was introduced in 2016 and perhaps because of that, along with the fact that it was frequently used in reports on the law change at the time, it seems to have to have entered common usage. I have even heard it used by members of the IFAB in press conferences.I understand the word 'genuine' was removed from the wording quite recently
The word 'genuine' was never in the main wording of the law to start with. It was however, included in the explanation given in the 'Details of Law changes' section when the change was introduced in 2016 and perhaps because of that, along with the fact that it was frequently used in reports on the law change at the time, it seems to have to have entered common usage. I have even heard it used by members of the IFAB in press conferences.
In The Netherlands as well. Here you have to fill out a short survey with questions if player was injured, could he continue and as last Q describe the situation. Works well and much quicker than writing it all down.Ah well, you do in Wales.
In The Netherlands as well. Here you have to fill out a short survey with questions if player was injured, could he continue and as last Q describe the situation. Works well and much quicker than writing it all down.
This area where a referee has to decide whether an attempt to get the ball is genuine or not is very tricky.
I've seen a couple of videos from the FA but no real guidance on this from the FA.
I'm told red cards for DOGSO in the area is down by over half in the amateur game (last season).
Think he was a Dutch player then manager.......CRUEF?????