Dare you.....ahh yes of course offside would be pretty harsh haha i'm just imagining myself administering a YC sunday.... '' sorry fella, thats your 6th offside...."
and then later... " thats your 8th... off you go"
would anyone ? would be hilariousDare you.....
By "penal" do you mean those punishable by a DFK? If so would you not caution for persistently impeding?In easy terms, it is the penal offences under Law 12.
While you could caution a player for PI for PIADM, it is more likely the caution would be for USB.
By "penal" do you mean those punishable by a DFK? /QUOTE]
Yes - that is what penal means.
Not quite the same but I threatened to caution a player if he took another sh!t shot at goal that flew off into the crowd! He thought I was joking...would anyone ? would be hilarious
Constant chipping, chuntering, all those little niggling things at corners - repetative intential jostling, taking a loooong time to come back to the 10 yds at FK, nudging the ball away when passed back for TI and FK's but not enought to YC for kiking away as it were ....... there comes a point where you've given then avisory (come on player, please - sigh ......) you've given warning, and then you've had enough - Player over here please. You may not have commited a YC offence as a whole but your persistant infringmenets themselves accumulate to a YC offence. I've spoken to you already but you just kept on.
In easy terms, it is the penal offences under Law 12.
While you could caution a player for PI for PIADM, it is more likely the caution would be for USB.
None of those are persistent infringement because you haven't acknowledged a law breach.
For a foul, for instance. A breach is acknowledged by a free kick or advantage. A verbal chat as you run past 'hey, you were getting a bit handsy in the tackle' cannot count towards PI as there was no infringement to start with.
So in every case you're quoted HRW, there has been no infringement. All of those are dealt with otherwise. Jostling before a CK? USB if he keeps doing it, or a PK if it's in play. Not retiring or nudging the ball away? Again, if you're only warning him then you're saying he hasn't breached the laws. If he has, it's a caution.
Why only penal offences?
Preventing the keeper for releasing the ball, for instance, would be cautionable for PI. As would repeated PIADM (say, a player keeps lifting the boot high in a crowded area).
Anything in Law 12....though I wouldn't be applying it to, say, keeper double handling or handling longer than 6 seconds.
That would fall under USB
Ok, thanks, as in it's part of unspecified behaviour under C1.
Surely as it can only be a yellow if the foultimate was a genuine attempt to play the ball it would be C1 and Foul Tackle