howard_webb
Well-Known Member
Check out @SkyFootball’s Tweet:
Polish referee gives it and then chnages his mind
Polish referee gives it and then chnages his mind
Correct me if I'm wrong, but the only possibilities here are penalty or dropped ball. You can't blow for a penalty, then apply a restart that happened after the fact.Was it because the AR gave offside? He doesn’t look offside but I’m questioning the restart. It looks like they are about to set up for a goal or free kick but at the very least it’s a corner
Was in 2009 tooIn 2019 thats 100% penalty kick.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but the only possibilities here are penalty or dropped ball. You can't blow for a penalty, then apply a restart that happened after the fact.
CorrectI guess on depends on whether the ball left the FOP before he blew (I had to listen with the sound off). If it left the FOP and then he signalled for the pen, couldn't he then go for the corner if he changes his mind?
No. The ball is out of play after the moment of the incident the referee blew the whistle for, even if he blew it much later. Timing of the whistle doesn't change that. In this case it was the moment of the handball as the referee signalled for a penalty.I guess on depends on whether the ball left the FOP before he blew (I had to listen with the sound off). If it left the FOP and then he signalled for the pen, couldn't he then go for the corner if he changes his mind?
The AR's said something that got the decision overturned so of course he's going to get applauded, I don't think that necessarily suggests offside though. And the keeper is also walking with the ball towards the camera - if there was an offside, it would be towards the far side of the PA. Having watched it again, I'm actually fairly sure there was just an off-camera drop ball and (apart from the terrible decision to not give a PK!!) everything has been done properly here.It's an offside from the video - keeper grabbed the ball and is walking it out and is also communicating positively with the AR.
That wouldn't matter, because then you wouldn't be able to give a penalty as the ball was out of play. @one summed it up perfectly.I guess on depends on whether the ball left the FOP before he blew (I had to listen with the sound off). If it left the FOP and then he signalled for the pen, couldn't he then go for the corner if he changes his mind?
You all need to have a hard look at yourselves.....never handball. Nothing deliberate about it...play on