ARS v CIT

[DJIC]

Taylor on his technical yellows today!

Would have liked one for Arteta, no need to be touching the ball, only one reason he did it. (Or is it in law a red card offence?)

 

[Degnann]

No chance you’ll see it in a tv match but technically Arteta delaying restart for opposing team there. No arguments if met with a red

 

[george.g]

Definitely looked like a penalty on first viewing there.

 

[george.g]

No chance you’ll see it in a tv match but technically Arteta delaying restart for opposing team there. No arguments if met with a red

Agree with the comment on TV game, however the general idea about consistency with technical offences should ideally apply here, but I understand there’s limitations

 

[george.g]

Definitely looked like a penalty on first viewing there.

Ruled offside. VAR looked to get that one right. Gabriel’s caution rescinded too

 

[george.g]

Grealish booked for dissent. Clearly told Taylor to eff off from sone basic lip reading

 

[AmitM]

I might be missing something, but I thought if the offside player hasn't interfered with play, then the foul stands?

 

[george.g]

Does the bottom point not indicate why it’s offside?

 

[DJIC]

OMG, a month’s worth of referee drama in 60 minutes.

VAR correctly over turns penalty, offside before, yellow rescinded.

Then a decision on SFP/VC on Haaland.

Dissent caution for Grealish.

 

[george.g]

OMG, a month’s worth of referee drama in 60 minutes.

VAR correctly over turns penalty, offside before, yellow rescinded.

Then a decision on SFP/VC on Haaland.

Dissent caution for Grealish.

3+ players surrounded Taylor maybe on that most recent caution, was expecting another dissent caution in there in all honesty

 

[James P]

dissent from saka towards the ar ignored?

 

[george.g]

dissent from saka towards the ar ignored?

Didn’t even see that

 

[AmitM]

Does the bottom point not indicate why it’s offside?

But he hadn't played the ball or challenged for it?

 

[george.g]

But he hadn't played the ball or challenged for it?

Ah, I thought he had by that point. In all honesty it feels offside, but it’s gonna be one of the more experienced members who can justify it in law

 

[DJIC]

Three quality teams on show tonight, delivering a great match for EPL.

 

[AmitM]

Ah, I thought he had by that point. In all honesty it feels offside, but it’s gonna be one of the more experienced members who can justify it in law

I haven't seen a replay yet so I may be wrong though!

 

[Jorik0907]

Think both Taylor today and Oliver yesterday have shown why they're the respective competition (near-) best referees

 

[GraemeS]

Think there's a legit penalty shout against Walker there, nowhere near the ball and significant contact on the attacker?

 

[es1]

Totally initiated by the attacker?

 

[GraemeS]

In that he's attempting to get the ball he's taken past the defender?