Latest activity
-
CCaptainsPlease replied to the thread Man Utd vs Man City.Because they awarded the later (wrong) offside offence, Haaland's, they have implicitly made a no offside decision against Fernandez...
-
Bbloovee replied to the thread Man Utd vs Man City.Sky were awful (during and after). MotD commentator, presumably listening to the feed, says they established that Haaland was onside and...
-
Wolf_Ref replied to the thread Man Utd vs Man City.I actually thought MO and his team did ok on the whole, but it is VAR that is both undermining and failing in its role. I thought... -
CCaptainsPlease replied to the thread Sheffield United vs Wolves.On the face of it Jones is caught out in a bad position but we don't have the context for that from the clip. I agree it is close...
-
Big Cat replied to the thread Sheffield United vs Wolves.It's a HB. Possibly blindside. AR1 ought to have seen it Jones was dreadful at St James Park the week before FWIW -
CCaptainsPlease replied to the thread Man Utd vs Man City.Am I right in thinking we have no indication yet as to whether the on-field officials gave an explanation regarding Fernandez's...
-
Big Cat replied to the thread Man Utd vs Man City.Offside. No excuses VAR in the bin again. WALOFS
-
PPaul_10 replied to the thread Man Utd vs Man City.Could be consequences for Matt Donohue as this is the second occasion where it's possible that he's misapplied the laws as a VAR(Palace...
-
zonknz replied to the thread Man Utd vs Man City.I would be genuinely curious to know if anyone at Pro Ref has a background in process design and/or safety engineering. There seems to... -
Ddadofref replied to the thread Man Utd vs Man City.From a cognitive point of view though, it's really not comparing apples and oranges. You don't need to be a top referee to run VAR. I...
-
FFinalWhistle replied to the thread Man Utd vs Man City.In cases like this where the refs have admitted that they made a mistake in a game changing decision, then the outcome should be...
-
FFinalWhistle replied to the thread Banned player seen playing...Looks like they got there in the end. Good that the suspensions aren't running concurrently, too.
-
FFinal update.. hopefully! Result: The cases have now been heard. The player received an additional five-match suspension, which will be...
-
FUpdate: Club and individual charged with playing while suspended, awaiting case(s) to be heard.
-
FNot currently, although I can ask the FA disciplinary team for an update.
