Latest activity
-
Lladbroke8745 replied to the thread Leeds v Brentford.I agree he may have gone easily but something seen online suggests pros, including ex ref Graham Scott, believe by not going down...
-
-
JamesL replied to the thread Maguire hb yay or nay.Ifab, at least in 2022, would disagree with your take on that. -
-
santa sangria replied to the thread Maguire hb yay or nay.I am happy with self defence at u12. But for any serious level, deliberately blocking the ball with the arms is a deliberate hb offence...
-
RRefereeX replied to the thread Middlesbrough vs West Bromwich Albion.I’m not saying it’s not a very poor decision for someone at that level, I’m saying why I think he’s got it wrong.
-
JamesL replied to the thread Maguire hb yay or nay.It's a reflex action. He's about to potentially get thumped in the chest area by the ball or opponent boot. No way your arms do anything...
-
JamesL replied to the thread Leeds v Brentford.Looks a clear pen to me. Only thing I think is that the player has gone down very easy. And I think that maybe sways it on motivation...
-
santa sangria replied to the thread Maguire hb yay or nay.Looks like deliberate handball to me. What else explains the movement and position of his arms?
-
JamesL replied to the thread Maguire hb yay or nay.Deliberate handball - no Made body unnaturally bigger - no Scored immediately in the opponents goal - no No handball offence committed.
-
santa sangria replied to the thread Leeds v Brentford.Looks clear and obvious to me.
-
Interesting situation. I had a pair of these at the weekend… but this was a big one on TV…
-
santa sangria replied to the thread Liverpool v Nottm Forest.Why even have boards at prem grounds with giant screens. Surely the EPL could ditch the boards completely. Seems archaic at this point...
-
Graham Scott makes a very valid point here, the boards aren't easy to use, I struggled sometimes when I had to use them and that was...
-
JamesL replied to the thread Liverpool v Nottm Forest.There is nothing in law that supports this so if the referee deemed the challenge to be careless, reckless or excessive force then a...
-
LI've deliberately delayed post to see if any one else asks the question.. Midway through second half Schade was, in my opinion, fouled...
-
Bbloovee replied to the thread Crewe goal.Treat them as "on the ball" incidents (where you can't be certain they were deliberate attempts to deceive) - but treat this as blatant...
