Latest activity
-
AARF replied to the thread Mexico vs South Africa.Without the foul the attacker would've had a free shot at goal from pretty much this exact position, and also had a teammate dead centre...
-
-
PPaul_10 replied to the thread Mexico vs South Africa.I agree the angle may of been getting tighter but it's still an obvious goal scoring opportunity imo, there was no covering defenders...
-
Ees1 replied to the thread Mexico vs South Africa.1st - dogso 2nd - wtf 3rd - dogso There endeth my review
-
RRustyRef replied to the thread Mexico vs South Africa.Fair point, I just don't think there was anywhere near enough violence in it. If we are sending off that that there are going to be red...
-
RRustyRef replied to the thread Mexico vs South Africa.No, because DOGSO has far more considerations than whether the attacker would have got a shot away. It probably ticks most of them, but...
-
AARF replied to the thread Mexico vs South Africa.As much as people may say the second red was either 'soft' or not a red, by the LotG it's violent conduct, as the contact to the head...
-
PPaul_10 replied to the thread Mexico vs South Africa.Well surely that is DOGSO then? That second DOGSO is exactly what the rule is there for surely because it was poor lazy defending and...
-
RRyanj91 replied to the thread Mexico vs South Africa.Not sure what was going on with the second red card? Mexican player put himself there and the SA action to move past him most certainly...
-
AI think a caution is probably a better outcome and nobody would be overly surprised, but I think it ticks enough boxes that dogso can’t...
-
Gabriel replied to the thread Mexico vs South Africa.The first red was obviously stonewall. I think the second was supportable but not C&O and VAR shouldn't have been getting involved, and... -
RRustyRef replied to the thread Mexico vs South Africa.I personally don't think it was DOGSO, but I can see why he gave it. Without the foul he is getting a shot away, albeit from a fairly...
-
HHilly1618 replied to the thread Mexico vs South Africa.It’s a DOGSO
-
OOri replied to the thread is women football better than mens?.Honestly, different challenges, but I do find the woman’s pathway less confrontational.
-
OOri replied to the thread Mexico vs South Africa.Sorry, but it either is DOGSO or isn’t DOGSO. If one of the criteria isn’t met then it isn’t DOGSO.
-
OI think a caution is probably a better outcome and nobody would be overly surprised, but I think it ticks enough boxes that dogso can’t...
