Substitution dismissal

[Redref34]

Hi all

Sorry really silly question but not happened to me before.

I have cautioned a substitute for dissent today then, as he continued, I have cautioned him again and therefore shown him the red. Does this go down on Whole Game as a playing dismissal or a non playing dismissal?
Thanks

 

[Will_A]

Playing dismissal as he was a substitute.
Non-playing is for managers/coaches etc.

There’ll be a box asking if the 1st caution was a sin bin, you’ll just have to explain that the offender was a substitute so it’s a straight C2.

 

[JamesL]

Like Will said he is a playing caution as he was a substitute. This would also apply to a substituted player as well.

There are 2 C2 options, one with sin bin and one without. Select the one without and it will ask you why the player was not sin binned.

 

[Wolf_Ref]

Well done! Had my first C2 second yellow last weekend - in a cup final.

Red #11 booked in first half for stopping a promising attack.

In 89th minute, red team equalise to make score 2-2. #11 a substitute atm (rolling subs). After goal celebrations, 4th official calls me over and notifies me that Red #11 (currently sub) entered FoP to celebrate goal. When asked to leave the field, tells 4th Official to F*** Off (bit rude…).

Very easy YC and sell - player hopped over the fence looking a bit embarrassed. But was interesting. He could have just said sorry mate and come off, but couldn’t behave himself.

Did make me chuckle afterwards.

 

[Redref34]

Well done! Had my first C2 second yellow last weekend - in a cup final.

Red #11 booked in first half for stopping a promising attack.

In 89th minute, red team equalise to make score 2-2. #11 a substitute atm (rolling subs). After goal celebrations, 4th official calls me over and notifies me that Red #11 (currently sub) entered FoP to celebrate goal. When asked to leave the field, tells 4th Official to F*** Off (bit rude…).

Very easy YC and sell - player hopped over the fence looking a bit embarrassed. But was interesting. He could have just said sorry mate and come off, but couldn’t behave himself.

Did make me chuckle afterwards.

Maybe 2 yellows for C2 doesn’t happen that much?!

My one was a shame, as the game was not like that at all.. player shouted at me from the sideline late on the game and I carded him, his defense was that he had to shout as I was across the other side of the pitch. Once carded he was still continuing so I just carded him again. He continued to protest after the game! Funny because when he was on the pitch he didn’t say a word to me!

Only 2 yellows and one red in the game all for dissent!

 

[Max2]

Had this happen yesterday (was on the line). Ref stuck someone in the bin for the ol' favourite of "you're having a f**king laugh, ref", then his side wanted to make a substitution before the restart. So player and ref were heading to the same place (away bench) about 5 yards apart. Sinbin'd player turns round and pops off to the ref accusing him of following him Ref just points to the sub getting ready to come on, so sinbin'd player helpfully adds that he was an Effing Cheating C, and out came the (straight) red. Joyous to watch. I'm sure there's some training point in here, but no sympathy for the player.

 

[Redref34]

I had to YC the opposition manger as well… his favourite phrase after subtly shouting at me was ‘I was talking to my own player’ … I said I’ll see you soon, he said ‘I hope not’ .. little does he know I am refereeing his cup final in a few weeks!

 

[Wolf_Ref]

Maybe 2 yellows for C2 doesn’t happen that much?!

My one was a shame, as the game was not like that at all.. player shouted at me from the sideline late on the game and I carded him, his defense was that he had to shout as I was across the other side of the pitch. Once carded he was still continuing so I just carded him again. He continued to protest after the game! Funny because when he was on the pitch he didn’t say a word to me!

Only 2 yellows and one red in the game all for dissent!

Yeah - this game was tame, in great spirits. Just one player who wanted to make it about him.

So far, one of the best games I’ve officiated - end to end and both teams wanted to play. Just that one player who couldn’t keep it shut…

 

[Gamespoiler]

Am I the only one that wouldn't give a second yellow here? To me this isn't dissent for telling the assistant ref to fk off, it would be a red.