The Ref Stop

Burnley Liverpool

The Ref Stop
I think 11 is offside from the head back.
Has the keeper got it? Not 100% sure. I think it's a combination of player getting to it at same time as keeper.
 
Anyone see the injury to Joe Gomez ?

Klopp moaning about a bad tackle, cant see anything wrong with it all ( did only see it in the boozer after the Everton game though)
 
spuddy1878 said:
Anyone see the injury to Joe Gomez ?

Klopp moaning about a bad tackle, cant see anything wrong with it all ( did only see it in the boozer after the Everton game though)
Click to expand...
I think the Joe Gomez tackle was actually fine, just unfortunately one of those where the landing is a little awkward. The tackle on Moreno that they flagged up on MOTD though...ouch!

I'd be disallowing the goal for the offside though - if that's not distracting the GK, I don't know what is. Agree with the others, if it was disallowed because the keeper had control I don't think it would be wrong, but I'm not convinced the ref's dropped one by not disallowing it for that reason. I just think the offside should have been enough!
 
GraemeS said:
I think the Joe Gomez tackle was actually fine, just unfortunately one of those where the landing is a little awkward. The tackle on Moreno that they flagged up on MOTD though...ouch!

I'd be disallowing the goal for the offside though - if that's not distracting the GK, I don't know what is. Agree with the others, if it was disallowed because the keeper had control I don't think it would be wrong, but I'm not convinced the ref's dropped one by not disallowing it for that reason. I just think the offside should have been enough!
Click to expand...

Didn't even give a free kick for the Moreno one!
 
GraemeS said:
I think the Joe Gomez tackle was actually fine, just unfortunately one of those where the landing is a little awkward. The tackle on Moreno that they flagged up on MOTD though...ouch!

I'd be disallowing the goal for the offside though - if that's not distracting the GK, I don't know what is. Agree with the others, if it was disallowed because the keeper had control I don't think it would be wrong, but I'm not convinced the ref's dropped one by not disallowing it for that reason. I just think the offside should have been enough!
Click to expand...
I watched the vid a few times with freeze frame. Couldn't get the exact moment but I don't think he is offside.

Screenshot_20181207-083131__01.jpg
 
one said:
Not sure what you are saying with those images.
Offside: the player clearly in offside position did not interfere. The player who interfered was level.
Control. If you go back one frame before the one you posted, you will see the keeper has control, two frames back you can still arguably say he has control.
Click to expand...
Why do I have to be saying anything? I just posted pictures of the contentious decisions.
If you want my opinion:
1) Player looks onside due to defender's foot.
2) Allison had control of the ball per LOTG.
We agree...
 
  • Like
Reactions: one
JH said:
Why do I have to be saying anything? I just posted pictures of the contentious decisions.
If you want my opinion:
1) Player looks onside due to defender's foot.
2) Allison had control of the ball per LOTG.
We agree...
Click to expand...
I didn't say you had to say something. I said if you were saying something without saying it, I wasn't sure what it was you were saying.
But now that you have said something, that something is what I would have said. :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: JH
Allison pretty obviously had control but the ref had stopped moving and was unsighted I think. How much would VAR have changed the games this midweek? Bton pen, Burnley goal, Utd goal...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top