The Ref Stop

Open Age A few issues

Donate to RefChat

Help keep RefChat running, any donation would be appreciated

TobyTheRef

New Member
Level 7 Referee
Had another interesting match on Sunday, which was my fifth after returning to refereeing and I'm just looking for a bit of guidance on a few issues from the good folks here.

Out of all the games I've had this season this was by far the most challenging, but I still enjoyed it:

1. Challenging CARs - I've had this two weeks in a row now, where the CARs have been a bit of a nightmare. Obviously their both set up at their respective LBs or last men, and they literally just flag offside for everything and anything, one team starts moaning about the other's CAR and then they instruct theirs to do the same which makes offsides obviously pretty difficult to manage. I've had words with both sides two weeks in a row and not much seems to change. Whether it's me or my positioning, but because I'm following the ball a lot of the time I find it difficult to be able to call an offside unless they're particularly obvious.

2. 50/50 tackles - Late in the game, away team 1-0 up and home team starting to push - ball breaks in the middle and two players both slide in for it making plenty of contact and both stay down - cue a bit of a mass con, though very minor, and it quickly broke up - I've always hated these types of situation, it's impossible to tell who has fouled who and where the offense really lies, I booked both as they were both reckless in the challenge, but any advice on how to look at these in the future.

Cheers, all!
 
The Ref Stop
Had another interesting match on Sunday, which was my fifth after returning to refereeing and I'm just looking for a bit of guidance on a few issues from the good folks here.

Out of all the games I've had this season this was by far the most challenging, but I still enjoyed it:

1. Challenging CARs - I've had this two weeks in a row now, where the CARs have been a bit of a nightmare. Obviously their both set up at their respective LBs or last men, and they literally just flag offside for everything and anything, one team starts moaning about the other's CAR and then they instruct theirs to do the same which makes offsides obviously pretty difficult to manage. I've had words with both sides two weeks in a row and not much seems to change. Whether it's me or my positioning, but because I'm following the ball a lot of the time I find it difficult to be able to call an offside unless they're particularly obvious.

2. 50/50 tackles - Late in the game, away team 1-0 up and home team starting to push - ball breaks in the middle and two players both slide in for it making plenty of contact and both stay down - cue a bit of a mass con, though very minor, and it quickly broke up - I've always hated these types of situation, it's impossible to tell who has fouled who and where the offense really lies, I booked both as they were both reckless in the challenge, but any advice on how to look at these in the future.

Cheers, all!
Regarding the challenging ARs, what I've tended to do in the past is a) look for an easy and impactless chance to overrule so that the opposition know that you're not just 100% taking their word for it and/or b) remember an occasion where a player may have looked offside but they didn't flag and remind the opposition about it when they accuse them of cheating.
I also like to remind people that it isn't a binary choice between 'the AR is cheating' or they're correct. They can be wrong by genuine mistake also.

Regarding the type of tackle you say... tough one, because you'd be within your rights to caution both, but then you have to give the free kick one way or the other and it's gonna be very tricky to sell a free kick in favour of a player you've just cautioned for his action.
If there is genuinely nothing to separate the 2 challenges then you're probably best off with a defensive free kick and a bollocking for both players that suggests a caution both ways is the right course of action and they're lucky.
 
Back
Top