A&H

Search results

  1. JamesL

    Open Age Overturning AR decision

    60 minutes? So was there not a conversation at half time and then an opportunity to quickly nip it on the bud at the start of half by sharing the explanation? And even still silently weathering the storm is not the approach. Ask. Tell. Warn. Report. And start having some action taken. 👍🏻
  2. JamesL

    Everton - Forest

    If you have aspirations of progressing I strongly recommend deleting that tweet. This won't be a good look if you get to an advanced level and people want to dig you out for something from your past, including your social media activity. There are also many referees who have found themselves on...
  3. JamesL

    Open Age Overturning AR decision

    This You need to confirm exactly why the flag was raised and then able to accurately relay this to everyone. Also be prepared for the absolute 💩 storm that follows. Correct outcome or not people will be unhappy that an incorrect flag went up.
  4. JamesL

    Spintso

    True, which I answered in my next paragraph 😁
  5. JamesL

    Spintso

    Well that could be explained by wanting to keep all performance data in one place and watches tend to be very individual and not offer real time monitoring from a third party device. That said there are features of the vests that should offer better performance than wrist based gps mainly not...
  6. JamesL

    Spintso

    They aren't allowed to wear watches but can wear a vest as per LOTG and the software offers tracking of everyone in realtime in a view of everyone. You'd expect them to be pretty accurate as well but I don't think that is the sole reason.
  7. JamesL

    Worth Appealing?

    Not really. You can't be double rewarded so if you've been rewarded in one section you can't use the same example to reward somewhere else unless its MCS and you want to reward positioning as an example.
  8. JamesL

    Spintso

    That can happen even with the premium watches. I have used Polar for many years being a proud owner of a v800, vantage V and currently rocking Grit X Pro. Aside from that a high end Garmin would be the best competition. Other alternatives are the vest things, catapult etc..
  9. JamesL

    Worth Appealing?

    Same here. Never had to appeal a report before. I do know that you can only appeal individual sections (e.g. 1.1, 2.2). You can only appeal on the basis that the written text is wrong in law or the mark awarded does not match the written text iirc For example the observer wrote you should...
  10. JamesL

    Lille vs Villa

    Apologies. It needed the context of the post i was replying to and to be honest I hadn't seen what had happened so it might not have made sense any road.
  11. JamesL

    Lille vs Villa

    The law only applies to goalkeepers, not players and was in this season's law changes
  12. JamesL

    Banned official

    You've nailed it. He is either a TA occupant or he isn't. That rules out a caution for the manager as we know who the offender is and he either leaves because he isn't allowed to be in the TA or he can stay because he is a TA occupant and has only been cautioned.
  13. JamesL

    Quick free kick

    Sometimes you just have to be wrong in law in the spirit of the game. This is one of those incidences.
  14. JamesL

    Dissent tolerance levels

    So far off topic. You'll be getting a warning ⚠️ 🤪 Still not changing it back...
  15. JamesL

    Dissent tolerance levels

    https://talksport.com/football/668253/dan-gosling-urges-referee-disgrace-jon-moss-apologise-zero-respect-bournemouth/
  16. JamesL

    Quick Free Kick Rule

    We've also got the definition of a quick free kick. "A free kick taken (with the referee’s permission) very quickly after play was stopped" Given all that happens between play stopping I can hardly say it sounds like a quick free kick. And where there is cautioning procedure play must be...
  17. JamesL

    Quick Free Kick Rule

    In the section guidelines to match officials. Sub heading body language communication and whistle
  18. JamesL

    GK handball Offence

    It can even be no card.
  19. JamesL

    Interesting observation

    What about a thank you? I think this might have come about from referees confronting observers after receiving a report with a lower mark than they think they should have gotten .
  20. JamesL

    Ifab question in LOTG

    If the Handball stops a promising attack two caution able offences occur sequentially. So it would be 2 yellow cards, 1 for simulation and 1 for stopping a promising attack by handball.
Back
Top