The Ref Stop

Search results

  1. P

    Arsenal Vs Hull

    Or it won't fit in Webb's insistence of how VAR works perfectly and we got to show the clips where it does work perfectly with the odd exception. However like the Palace v Chelsea case last year, I'll be disappointed if this does not get shown because I think transparency is key, if the...
  2. P

    Arsenal Vs Hull

    I think we should just see what the audio says(if they release it) before we cast too many judgments. Maybe the referee as apparently being an ex footballer at a certain level used his "common sense" approach and give the offside whilst perhaps forgetting or not knowing the law as it's written.
  3. P

    Arsenal Vs Hull

    Except as Dale Johnson posted, this has happened before and it was explained on the mic'd up show the law itself and the logic behind it. I hope we do hear the audio on it but like Palace v Chelsea last season where a VAR may of misinterpreted the law, it was not shown and I wouldn't be...
  4. P

    Arsenal Vs Hull

    I suspect and hope this gets played on the next mic'd up show because I'm curious whether the VAR highlighted the offside and tells the ref the offside should come before the foul or was it the referee decided the offside should take precedence over any foul. If it's the first one then why...
  5. P

    Leeds v Spurs

    I'm only basing that on Pro Ref's way of how they deal with these things with "referees call". Ive never liked it as I think it can make the VAR's job much harder than it already is and we shouldn't be going down the route that a VAR intervention is re refereeing when the ref ultimately has the...
  6. P

    Leeds v Spurs

    I agree about the Darren Fletcher comments, it's not just refereeing decisions it's decisions of players and be quite critical of players at times, surely that is more of the job of the co commentator. That said, i do think the VAR should of intervened here, surely John Brooks has not seen that...
  7. P

    Leeds v Spurs

    Couple of controversial calls in that first half with a potential handball and red card with neither given. I think the handball decision is correct and even more so when TNT showed that angle which apparently the VAR does not have access too as it clearly comes off the shoulder yet the angle...
  8. P

    Liverpool vs Arsenal

    Well he even said he wouldn't of intervened if he was on VAR but it would of been interesting what the sanction would of been had a VAR did intervened. Just because you have not seen it happened before means you can't rule out a red card occuring here. Despite the noise, I can see why the VAR...
  9. P

    Fleetwood v Arsenal

    Come on Rusty, he said a few words with a stern look, if we really going down that route then I'm guessing teachers are not aloud to shout at students these days? The reaction to it has been pathetic really, if Arteta was screaming in his ear and shoving him then totally different story but...
  10. P

    Fleetwood v Arsenal

    Unlike the Botman challenge on Jackson, the contact is low, cleanly gets the ball and it feels a bit more unfortunate that Dowman's leg got trapped like that. With Botman's, his contact was more on top of the ball, in less control and it probably only down to less force that Jackson did not...
  11. P

    Fleetwood v Arsenal

    Nope I always believe it's the other way round because upgrading a yellow to a red is seen less of an error than the other way round but when you got no VAR and a official sees a player kicking out then it gives you a decision to be made and your instinct will surely lead more to a red card.
  12. P

    Fleetwood v Arsenal

    I wouldn't be surprised if it was the assistant who probably made that decision for the ref there as I doubt Salisbury would of seen that from his position. However I do think its harsh though, it's definitely just more petulant than violent. Good point made about whether the lack of influence...
  13. P

    Sunderland v Brighton DOGSO

    What's really disappointing for me is this incident was not included on mic'd up show but instead show a straight forward obvious refereeing error in the City Ipswich game which then you have Webb claiming this is a good use of VAR which it was but it was such an obvious situation there was...
  14. P

    Lincoln - West Ham

    Said it before and I say it again, I think the word reckless to describe a yellow card tackle is not the right word to use because virtually everyone(and there is intelligent people out there who also say it) associates the word reckless as dangerous therefore thinking reckless tackle is a red...
  15. P

    Sunderland v Brighton DOGSO

    Think the issue was that the referee did not even award a foul so there's a clear and obvious error and that foul in the VAR mind was a DOGSO hence the review. I really don't see the debate here though, if the defender did not foul the attacker, he would of regained the ball and have a shot at...
  16. P

    Sunderland v Brighton DOGSO

    Seems I'm in the minority but this looks like a DOGSO too me, the keeper was not running towards the ball and the ball was much closer to the attacker when the foul happened. If the keeper was running towards the ball then fair enough but for me the attacker was most definately getting to that...
  17. P

    Liverpool - Man C

    I thought it was the correct decision aswell, Doku was breaking forward and it was a cynical trip. No doubt we will hear comments the red card ruined the game but it was not the best game before that and Liverpool have played very poorly with 10 men unlike their opponents when they were down to...
  18. P

    West Ham v QPR

    Funny ain't it that their is journalists who want VAR scrapped(and I'm sure Winter is one of those) and wants the refs to make the decisions but when we see bad decisions being made, the clamour for VAR is there. I think VAR in the championship will arrive sooner rather than later, the noise...
  19. P

    Man Utd vs Man City

    Hearing the audio and I think this for me reflects badly more on the AVAR because his complete silence during the whole check is unhelpful and he should be there as those extra pair of eyes on the footage and should be 100% concentrated. The process for the SAOT does seem quite a bit of a faff...
  20. P

    Man Utd vs Man City

    Disallowed goal with most people thinking Haaland strayed offside going by the camera angle(as Neville was so adamant that was the case). One thing I have found slightly amusing in Carraghers analysis last night was the Foden red card. Pundits have been criticizing refs for not making on field...
Back
Top