The Ref Stop

Search results

  1. C

    Leeds v Everton

    The first time I saw this I thought I would not be giving that with how close the arm is to the body. But then from other angles you see how much he has moved to get in the way. You take the risk you pay the price and it is definitely not a decision for VAR to overturn. I'm sure this will get...
  2. C

    Observation

    It is difficult to tell at the moment what marking will end up like overall because of the new marking scheme for this season. I got slightly over 71 for my first observation last week which I felt was fair.
  3. C

    EFL OFFINABUS

    A (minimum) second caution being issued here would have been praised beyond refereeing circles and demonstrated the various behaviour campaigns are not just empty words as far as the professional game is concerned.
  4. C

    8 second law example

    This is the inevitable outcome of writing law that doesn't mean what it says.
  5. C

    San Jose vs Vancouver

    I think the penalty is justifiable as a holding offence.
  6. C

    FA Cup replay ordered due to officiating error

    Thanks I have corrected my original post. The Laws of the Game are also clear that unused substitutions may be used in extra time.
  7. C

    Puma Football Boots

    I wear the King Tops and very happy with them.
  8. C

    FA Cup replay ordered due to officiating error

    It has been publicised that the Bridlington Town v Knaresborough Town FA Cup Extra Preliminary Round Replay that was played last Tuesday will be replayed tonight. During extra time Knaresborough, the side that lost the tie, was refused their 5th substitution (3 in normal time + 2 in extra time)...
  9. C

    8 seconds not being enforced

    So far I have found that a shout to the goalkeeper the first time they have only a few seconds left is enough to remind them to get rid of it. After that the compliance is pretty good without counting out loud etc. It probably makes an easy proactive/preventative development point for an...
  10. C

    Championship week 1 incidents

    I was going to ask from the Southampton v Wrexham match should Edwards have been penalised for DOGSO when conceding the penalty for shoving in the back? There was not even a caution given but I personally would have not minded him being sent off given the circumstances and it did not appear to...
  11. C

    Keeper water bottle

    Sorry I've posted a duplicate thread (and poll) but my thinking is no one is entitled to a written aid that they haven't kept on their person so would not take action.
  12. C

    Hampton admits throwing Spain GK's penalty notes into crowd

    Right if we notice this as a ref should we caution or not!
  13. C

    Jewellery

    For what purpose?
  14. C

    MOAS "Provisional" Appointments

    Lots of good info above about how these are being used more this season. I have seen it myself with a Step 4 AR appointment.
  15. C

    Luton v Wimbledon

    @Russell Jones @JamesL @socal lurker you were correct and I'm glad this came up for me now rather than later!
  16. C

    Dropped ball IFAB confirmation

    Following from this thread. I may be in a minority of one who read too much from the Law 8 change, but this may be of some use to others in case of any doubt. IFAB has confirmed via email that when play stops from the ball changing possession after striking a match official, the ball is...
  17. C

    LOTG 25/26 Briefing

    Well presented :)
  18. C

    Women's football

    Be on top of jewellery / equipment. Participants may be accustomed to a lower threshold for fouls. I find there tends to be fewer verbal issues but when it occurs can escalate quickly, so be alert as usual! Finally I would say there is often less appealing for decisions so don't be deterred from...
  19. C

    EFL 2 August incidents

    Yeah I was imagining a possible appeal along the lines of 'advantage played so was wrong to go back to the foul', though this was quick enough to go back in law so shouldn't really be a successful argument, it can look like giving two bites when signalling like that.
  20. C

    EFL 2 August incidents

    I'd say it's a stretch to say he didn't signal advantage when we see his arm signal first and then only blowing the whistle when the GK won out in the following challenge. Don't think he'd have blown if the attacker had got past! Second one there is a closer angle that was shown on ITV...
Back
Top