The Ref Stop

Search results

  1. F

    goalkeeper sent off for handball - dogso?

    Right, I can see that the keeper handballed it, but why a red card and not just a yellow? Is it because it looked like that header would have gone in, maybe?
  2. F

    Everton - Forest

    Forest have demanded that referee audio of the incidents be released to the public domain. https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/articles/clw0g501q0xo
  3. F

    Everton - Forest

    Hypothetically assuming that the accusations are right, is it still inappropriate to make them in public? I have a feeling it might be and perhaps should only be made through the official channel. btw, I have no opinion on them one way or the other as I didn't see the incidents, just curious.
  4. F

    Dissent tolerance levels

    @Viridis1886 I can't wait for them to bring the sin bin to the Premier League and Champions League. It's so humiliating for the naughty player to be made to sit in the naughty spot for a bit, lol. Do the players get all grumbly when they're forced to sit it out? Also, is it the ref who times...
  5. F

    Ghost goals over the decades

    This fascinating video shows lots of ghost goals over the decades due to incorrect reffing decisions. Of course, these errors happened due to the difficulty of seeing these fast action edge cases in real time with the naked eye and no available replays. It's interesting to see as how technology...
  6. F

    Dissent tolerance levels

    The thread starter doesn't state any particular level of reffing, so it was reasonable to bring in the situation where VAR and the monitor are available as one possible scenario. I agree that constantly asking questions isn't acceptable as it's just a form of trolling and undermining the ref...
  7. F

    Mental health

    @Hazzy this sounds awful. From what I understand, reffing is more of a vocation, a passion, rather than about the money, so if things don't improve then it might be best to give up on it. I certainly wouldn't want to take relentless abuse for anything, whether paid or not. Hope the situation...
  8. F

    Dissent tolerance levels

    Ah, experience! 😂
  9. F

    Dissent tolerance levels

    Ok, I was referring to where they do have a monitor such as in PL or CL games. If there's no other way to double check, then of course, you can't just go by what the player's claiming and I wasn't suggesting that. Ok, so where there's VAR, which is the scenario I was thinking of, then it's...
  10. F

    Dissent tolerance levels

    Sorry, I don't see where it's confusing. Not sure how to clarify it further.
  11. F

    Dissent tolerance levels

    ok cool. Now, let's consider the scenario where our hypothetical polite player happens to be right. Shouldn't the ref then change his mind, or at least review the incident on the monitor?
  12. F

    Dissent tolerance levels

    If a player comes up to the ref, politely disagrees and attempts to explain why the decision was wrong and hence change his mind, is that still an offense?
  13. F

    Protecting face with hand

    Not giving handball for a reflexive, defensive movement to prevent injury sounds sensible to me. @bester thanks for that quote, very helpful. 🙂 I've seen in the PL with VAR replays where it looks like a grey area regarding defensive / deliberate / arm in the wrong place etc where it can take...
  14. F

    Advice regarding verbal abuse/confidence

    Too right. Some great advice in this thread, too.
  15. F

    Timekeeping and 4th Official

    Oh agreed, I meant more generally. Introducing them next season sounds sensible. I have a feeling that cost might be a significant factor though.
  16. F

    Timekeeping and 4th Official

    Sounds like you could really do with a radio like they have in the pro games.
  17. F

    Howdy!

    lol me neither.
  18. F

    Make the Forum Rules easier to find

    Yer welcome, RR. You can actually add it in the styles / templates to the menu. I've done it on my forum in the Help section, for an example. This way you don't change the Terms and Rules link, but add another for Forum Rules like I've done (no limit to how many menu items you can add). When...
  19. F

    Howdy!

    Loving these c-cup confessions. Keep 'em coming lads - the more potentially career ending the better! 😁
  20. F

    Chelsea v Manchester United soft penalties

    I see it's been handily moved to there now. 🙂 The second bit I dunno, but I see where you're coming from. I think subjectiveness is inherent in the game as things can so often be interpreted different ways, especially from different camera angles and realtime v slowmo.
Back
Top