The Ref Stop

Search results

  1. F

    Scotland v Switzerland

    I see that the own goal by Schar at 12 minutes got changed to a McTominay goal, but I can't see the logic of that. McTominay's shot was on target, but was going to pass fairly close to the keeper, who might well have saved it. However, Schar's attempt to stop the ball with his foot massively...
  2. F

    GER v SCO - Euro 24

    I like the quick offside decisions with the new technology. Big improvement.
  3. F

    VAR voted 19-1 to continue for next season, but with improvements

    I'm in favour of VAR since improving decision accuracy is critical despite a few high profile gaffs, so I'm happy with this decision. Here's a couple of articles on this decision...
  4. F

    CAR’s

    Sorry, I don't have an answer for you, but I do have an observation: in some ways, the higher level reffing where they have VAR I would say is easier, since you have technology to help you out and you don't have to rely on people's honesty about situations. There is of course, lots of pressure...
  5. F

    One bad observer down…

    Oh yeah, being freelance they have zero responsibility towards him anyway and owe him nothing, so he's definitely not coming back from this now. He's tainted goods. One can't just say racist crap like this in this day and age.
  6. F

    One bad observer down…

    Thanks for the clarification, JamesL. How stuff like that can ever be considered not abusive or insulting is beyond me. I get laddish humour when friends make insulting jokes to each other that they laugh off, but racism is a red line that should never be crossed.
  7. F

    One bad observer down…

    That sounds like a case of "casual racism" to me and it's probably likely that he didn't mean it maliciously, as he's claimed. However, it's still just as unacceptable as "regular" racism said with bad intent though, so they can't be soft on it, especially for a second offence. Such a stupid and...
  8. F

    First game yesterday - felt like walking away

    Oh man, walk away, not worth getting your head kicked in over this with potentially life changing injuries. They sound like a bunch of thugs, not a football team. Definitely report it and add as much detail as possible.
  9. F

    Conned - Maybe...?

    Confusing everybody sounds like a result! 🤣 Seriously, it totally fits in with my sense of humour and irony. But really, great feedback from everyone here. Sounds like it's technically possible, but not worth it if you wanna live afterwards lol. Reffing can really be a minefield.
  10. F

    Conned - Maybe...?

    Ok, so what about a yellow for clear simulation and allow the free kick?
  11. F

    Conned - Maybe...?

    Oh, I'd give him a yellow card for clearly cheating - and no free kick. The only way to stop these antics is to take away the profit. Surely the rules would allow you to do this?
  12. F

    Hanging up whistle

    @JBeil 40 quid for all that time and commitment just to get all that aggro? No way, not worth it. I wouldn't do it either and I think you're right to quit. At most, perhaps try women's football as others have suggested. Certainly, the ladies are generally more well behaved and naturally less...
  13. F

    Man U v Arsenal

    Give Ratcliffe a chance! He's only just joined and all these big things take time and money, lots of money.
  14. F

    VAR Vote

    For all its faults and issues, I think VAR should stay. I like the forensic level analysis of incidents and overall it improves reffing quality. I believe that the process will continue to improve over time. Don't forget that the side on the wrong end of a VAR decision will nearly always...
  15. F

    Man U v Arsenal

    @RustyRef interesting, but as many other stadiums don't have these features and they don't waterlog, these slopes all round the pitch aren't needed to achieve adequate drainage. I suspect that advancements in technology have mitigated this. I've never noticed that slope either and no tendency...
  16. F

    Man U v Arsenal

    I don't get why the Old Trafford pitch is made that way as there's no need for it. I've been there and can tell you that the drop-off is high and steep, the camera doesn't lie. With Ratcliffe now at the helm and his desire to overhaul the stadium as part of his overall plans for the club, maybe...
  17. F

    goalkeeper sent off for handball - dogso?

    Hangonaminute! So, you're saying that a reffing expert, ie the ref and the VAR team are being judged by non-reffing experts and potentially partisan people, the ex players and managers? Something isn't right here. An appeal should only be judged by top refs, end of story.
  18. F

    Everton - Forest

    With such obvious reffing errors, one can see why people sometimes think a decision was fixed, even if it wasn't. I haven't seen it, so am not expressing an opinion on it, just going by your account.
  19. F

    goalkeeper sent off for handball - dogso?

    But guys, why is this incident worth a red card and not just a yellow?
  20. F

    goalkeeper sent off for handball - dogso?

    The ball had only just started its trajectory when the keeper blocked it, plus the angle viewed at, so it doesn't look certain to me. Remember, the ref saw it from a very different angle than the camera and that can make a real difference to perception. There's no VAR in this game either, I believe.
Back
Top