The Ref Stop

Search results

  1. bester

    Sheffield Wednesday vs Plymouth

    Many refs seem to have a blind spot regarding the severity of goalkeeper challenges.
  2. bester

    England Vs Croatia

    Sustained pulling on Quansah, VAR rightly sends the red to the monitor. Wouldn't have been given in EPL as he wasnt getting on the end of it
  3. bester

    Arsenal Vs Hull

    This is about as textbook as you can get with what IFAB meant as not an offside offence. You get some edge cases with this part of the law but this certainly isn't one of the them.
  4. bester

    Plaster as Shinpad

  5. bester

    Arsenal Vs Hull

    @Paul_10 If the ball wasn't heading towards the offside player then VAR would determine the pull has no impact on the game and not give a penalty for that reason. Red herring in this one as the foul is made before the pass, the defender doesn't even know where it's going for sure. Don't find...
  6. bester

    Arsenal Vs Hull

    Apparently the attacker being pulled was interfering with an opponent, the pull starts before the pass was even made Some strange explanations given too Dale Johnson from PGMO as well https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/articles/c6rmyg7xpnj1o
  7. bester

    Everton Vs Coventry - Hair Pulling

    @RustyRef Don't think that's the case overall, only people who don't know the advice changed are saying it should be a red based on past past precedents. It can't possibly be a red last season, and now not even careless The instructions that it was a red card were wrong last season despite...
  8. bester

    Penalty - Completed "runup"?

    It technically could be construed as feint for me. Once he plants that left foot the runup is complete, he then pulls his right foot backwards and plants it on the ground before kicking the ball. Good view from 55 seconds.
  9. bester

    Leeds v Spurs

    From this view I'd be very surprised if part of the ball isn't striking his arm below the 'arm pit line' The second one suggests top marginal to call. On field decision either way
  10. bester

    Everton Vs Coventry - Hair Pulling

    This would've been a red card last season it's not even classed as careless
  11. bester

    Penalty - Completed "runup"?

    Bizarre refereeing. Strange one.
  12. bester

    Fleetwood v Arsenal

    @socal lurker That panel member described Dowman's action as "a challenge".
  13. bester

    Fleetwood v Arsenal

  14. bester

    New LoTG - Injuries - Liking it!!

    Exempt it from under 18 football, the FA are s***hot on verbals issues but seem laissez-faire towards physical ones. Not a referee issue but allowing micro shin-pads is an example of this culture. You can be sure players are being instructed not to call the physio on even when they need it
  15. bester

    Coventry Vs Sunderland - Hair Pull

  16. bester

    Villa Vs Fulham

    The goalkeeper must not behave in a way that unfairly distracts the kicker, e.g. delay the taking of the kick or touch the goalposts, crossbar or goal net. Distract Disturb, confuse or draw attention (usually unfairly)
  17. bester

    Man C v BHA - backpass claim

    I don't think there's any doubt he's knocking it back to the goalkeeper deliberately. It's not desperate interception he knows exactly what he's doing. If he wanted to clear it he'd have swung his left foot at it but risk of going in to the net. Still not giving it as a pass back, more blatant...
  18. bester

    Villa Vs Fulham

  19. bester

    Fleetwood v Arsenal

    Under 18 players named on the bench, they may have been warming up.
Back
Top