The Ref Stop

Search results

  1. R

    Coventry v Newcastle

    Makes me laugh to think how many times players must wear shirts with messages on to reveal when they score, get thumped 3-0 and the message never sees the light of day 😁
  2. R

    Coventry v Newcastle

    Not my job to determine how political a message is or isn't. That's for the authorities post match. In my opinion the punishment (if any) on field should be the same regardless of what the message is.
  3. R

    Liverpool - Man C

    Spot the Liverpool fan 😆. Yes, he steps on his foot. No it's not deliberate. The force is as expected for that sort of situation, and as I said above, a mandatory caution in many places / situations, even if not written in law. I don't mind the opinion that it's a harsh caution or even that...
  4. R

    mıstaken ıdentıty

    No. Unless you're being consistently poorly marked by clubs and there is a clear pattern, then the local FA may raise the concern with you and it could affect your promotion, but a couple of low marks from disgruntled clubs won't count against you.
  5. R

    Liverpool - Man C

    100% he caught him on top of the foot - not to say Anderson didn't exaggerate it, but it was definitely enough for a caution in places where that guidance has been given.
  6. R

    Liverpool - Man C

    Not sure you can say the caution is objectively wrong when Gravenberch's studs came down on top of Anderson's foot. In a lot of competitions thats a mandatory caution.
  7. R

    Classic offside lesson

    Possible step 5/6 referee vs step 2 specialist AR :hmmm:
  8. R

    Classic offside lesson

    In fairness, perhaps the AR thinks he's doing the right thing by giving himself a head start so that he's at the business end where the ball will be knocked in in case of any issues or a goal line judgement to make. He's wrong, of course, but there's a degree of effort there.
  9. R

    Paris Vs Arsenal Ladies

    I think it's always a dangerous situation when a referee doesn't know for certain if a restart has been taken or not... for similar reasons I don't allow corner shenanigans where a team will nudge the ball in the arc then run away and someone else comes and gets the ball and runs with it. At...
  10. R

    Paris Vs Arsenal Ladies

    Fair, but then advantage is played again until the handball offence which is the best benefit to the non-offending team... ;) It has been made very, very clear to English officials that this is the expectation, so yes, if it happens and I notice that it's happened (I do think if you're not...
  11. R

    Paris Vs Arsenal Ladies

    I don't think the ball is ever stationary inside the goal area before it settled just prior to the last kick where he is then deemed to have taken it before the handball. For what its worth... I'd imagine absolutely nobody expected a penalty here and everyone was shocked... BUT... if referees...
  12. R

    Classic offside lesson

    It's actually a trickier decision than it initially appears, because the player who receives the ball is only very fractionally over the half way line when it's played, although it is indeed correct.
  13. R

    Paris Vs Arsenal Ladies

    I'd argue it's had a huge impact on the game with teams taking short goal kicks all the time and playing out from the back more.
  14. R

    Paris Vs Arsenal Ladies

    I don’t hate the idea in principle but sometimes GKs have minor leg niggles that mean they continue to play in goal but can’t kick the ball long. Seems a little unfair to effectively penalise a team for this and only ever give them the option of playing short
  15. R

    Real W vs City W

    The only concern for me with impeding a player being treated the same is that players should make an active effort to avoid the referee in the same way that referees should avoid players (imo). I don’t want to open the door to a world where a player who isn’t getting to their opponent will run...
  16. R

    Real W vs City W

    Incorrect in law... but I've done it before in the right scenario. It's right for the game IMO. Very unlucky that it's resulted in a goal. With that said, you're gonna piss someone off either way if the ball goes in, so you'd rather be correct in law and piss someone off than incorrect in law...
  17. R

    Penalty goalkeeper 'protest'

    I would imagine a coincidence. The way I read law, the goalkeeper not facing the kick would be no different to him being off his line... therefore if the kicker scores no issue, only a retake if keeper saves it.
  18. R

    Referee Whistle Lanyards

    Ahh egg chasing. Fair enough.
  19. R

    Referee Whistle Lanyards

    I was just intrigued because I don't know anyone who uses a pea whistle in football refereeing. I struggle to get enough sound out of the 'high tech' whistles!
  20. R

    Referee Whistle Lanyards

    Out of interest, is that the actual whistle you use while refereeing in the top photo?
Back
Top