The Ref Stop

Search results

  1. R

    First adult game last week...my thoughts

    That almost certainly breaks the forum record for resurrecting a (very) old post 😂
  2. R

    Replay due to misapplication of law

    There are several precedents for this, it will always result in a replay. And the 4 officials will be looking for something to do for the next 21 days as they certainly won't be refereeing football games. As for the original decision, I suspect Woodford just asked a question originally and the...
  3. R

    Stoke v Sheffield United

    They wore their 3rd choice outfield kit ... And their away keeper kit ... Probably doesn't look too bad at pitch level. Can only assume they couldn't use their 3rd choice keeper kit as deemed to be too red to potentially clash with Stoke. There were probably limited choices, clearly...
  4. R

    Brighton v Arsenal

    I'm normally all for sanctioning a kick when the ball is nowhere near as VC, but this was much more of a trip than a kick and it is probably a push to say it used excessive force or brutality. Certainly not enough for VAR to get involved.
  5. R

    Junior/Youth Young referee – intimidating behaviour from manager & linesman. What should I do?

    There can only really be a discipline issue if sanctions have been issued by the referee during the game. At grass roots it is very difficult for CFAs to start disciplinary proceedings where no cards have been issued. But safeguarding is different and they can implement proceedings there...
  6. R

    Man Utd vs Man City

    As it was given offside people would have just accepted it as Haaland looked from the TV angle. Had the goal been given the broadcasters would have drawn their own lines, incorrectly, said the assistant was wrong and demanded there should be technology to help the officials.
  7. R

    Man Utd vs Man City

    This bit strikes me as worrying, pretty sure that isn't in the VAR protocol.
  8. R

    Man Utd vs Man City

    No, it is correct that he has been a VAR, but he isn't a specialist VAR. I'm not sure there are any such creatures after the failed experiment with Mike Dean and Lee Mason.
  9. R

    Man Utd vs Man City

    If you mean Matt Donohue he definitely isn't specialist VAR, he's refereed several Championship games so far this season. I may be wrong but I don't recall him having been an EFL assistant, but he obviously would have assisted at some level even if just L4.
  10. R

    Man Utd vs Man City

    That's comparing apples with oranges. An air traffic controller doesn't need to know how to fly a plane as they will never have to do it, likewise a pilot doesn't need to know how to operate ATC as they are never going to be in that position. A VAR official needs to have experience of making...
  11. R

    Sheffield United vs Wolves

    There's also a debate as to whether it was intentional under Pro Ref guidelines. The ball travelled a very short distance and it could be deemed an instinctive reaction, probably a handball but I certainly don't think it was an absolute howler not to give it.
  12. R

    Man Utd vs Man City

    Really? So that would make Peter Drury and Gary Neville part of the 0.001% as they didn't have a clue what was going on even though they had access to the VAR audio, yes they'd have got the offside correct but not for the correct reason. For at least 5 minutes Neville, who in his defence is...
  13. R

    Man Utd vs Man City

    A gentle reminder, we do not allow fan posts on here and some posts are going down that route. Make an opinion on the decision by all means, but at least justify your reasoning under the law. I knew there would be an apology, but thought it would be at least tomorrow, the fact it has happened...
  14. R

    Man Utd vs Man City

    This does impact an opponent though, if Fernandez isn't there there's a more than good chance that Martinez can get across to block Haaland's shot. And the keeper could also have shuffled over, which he obviously couldn't do with Fernandez trying to head it. I'd say there is a very strong...
  15. R

    Man Utd vs Man City

    Them being told to stay central doesn't help matters, much more risk of being hit by the ball in the middle of the pitch. I guess the counter argument is it doesn't really matter now as play is stopped if it happens, whereas in days gone by the ball hitting the referee could change a game.
  16. R

    Sunderland v Arsenal

    I don't disagree with you that he got the wrong man, but I don't think it was because he mistook Konsa for Gabriel, rather he has just made a mess in terms of recognition of what actually happened. We've all done it when there's a confrontation where we lose one or both of the instigators, but...
  17. R

    Man Utd vs Man City

    I have no idea how they came to that conclusion. The post on the PL Match Centre says Fernandez isn't offside as he didn't touch the ball, but him being there in an offside position certain impacts Martinez and arguably also the keeper. If Fernandez wasn't there Martinez could have moved...
  18. R

    Sunderland v Arsenal

    I was saying that I don't think VAR could have got involved on the basis the caution for Gabriel was mistaken identity. I would agree that the referee mistook Gabriel pulling players away for an involvement worthy of a caution, but that isn't mistaken identity. It would be mistaken identity if...
  19. R

    Sunderland v Arsenal

    I wouldn't say it was mistaken identity, rather was a misjudgement of who the worst offender from Arsenal was.
  20. R

    Arsenal vs Chelsea

    It’s a Pro Ref directive, don’t remember Messi ever playing in the EPL / EFL
Back
Top