The Ref Stop

Search results

  1. JamesL

    Interfering with play?

    If we are talking about blue 9 here then he is "clearly attempting to play a ball which is close when this action impacts on an opponent" so in my opinion he commits an offside offence. You say you buzzed for a potential offside. How was that resolved? As the referee I'd want to know what that...
  2. JamesL

    Man United Vs Leeds - Hair Pulling

    In most cases pulling someone hair is a savage act. I haven't seen this incident so I can't say for sure it it meets the threshold to be considered savage but I don't think we need a great deal of force before we arrive at the point of calling it violent conduct.
  3. JamesL

    Man United Vs Leeds - Hair Pulling

    Not sure but done a dig and pulled out a reply to a facebook post:
  4. JamesL

    Real Madrid v Girona

    Beauty is in the eye of the beholder... I actually quite like it.
  5. JamesL

    How often do you dish out sinbin yellow?

    I dont have them now as I operate at a level when they aren't in use and in the small number of games that I do where they are I've had no occasion too. Sin bins don't necessarily indicate anything. For example in the year I got promoted, granted sin bins were new and so I think there's...
  6. JamesL

    Time is time...

    Fine balance if the winning team then concede well after any indicated amount of time. I keep saying this but context matters if it's literally just gone time then maybe we don't stop it. A short amount of seconds is easily explainable. Already let it go a little longer then we have to climb up...
  7. JamesL

    Martinelli incident - Southampton vs Arsenal FA Cup QF

    Quick Google search turns up the above published by IFAB at the start of this season. I'm in the this is not enough for a red card camp but I 100% support and accept those that would issue a red card. As with all things context is exceptionally important and that context changes on a lot of...
  8. JamesL

    Hated AR

    Exactly
  9. JamesL

    Doncaster v Mansfield - Offside

    The simple answer here was that he was not in the optimum position. We, that is assistant referees operating at steps 2-6, were recently given some training that showed the impact of being in the wrong position, the angle changes what you see and therefore makes detecting offside even more...
  10. JamesL

    USA v Belgium kit clash

    I think on the ground this would not have looked that bad which is why the game proceeded. Not great for the Tele but certainly can distinguish enough in that clip to say it was probably not as evident to the match officials.
  11. JamesL

    Referee social media accounts.

    I have come off all the mainstream social media platforms through personal choice. Whilst I would share personal achievements I didnt actively promote my refereeing. Social media can be used for good, and I do see things I miss out on by not being on there. It all comes down to the user at the...
  12. JamesL

    Bournemouth vs Man United

    Username suggests not a referee themselves but the dad of one.
  13. JamesL

    Celtic v Motherwell

    This is the challenge of VAR. The answer I think probably that they wouldn't have recommended a downgrade (obviously we don't know what we don't know). When the VAR reviews they look at the decision that has been made and determine if that decision is clearly and obviously wrong. This is...
  14. JamesL

    Bournemouth vs Man United

    Unpopular opinions it seems but both were pens for me. The holding clearly impeded Cunhas movement, and although he dived theatrically the fact that not a single Bournemouth player argued the decision tells you enough for me. The Amad one in the build up to the goal was more of expected...
  15. JamesL

    Bournemouth vs Man United

    I said there would be at least 8. There was a delay after Bournemouth first goal. A delay to confirm man utd penalty. A delay to confirm the Maguire red. There was a no pen check too if I recall. + Subs and injuries then added on time felt about right without needing to time it. Not sure this...
  16. JamesL

    HARD yellow & red cards

    https://amzn.eu/d/0hgsqIsE Like these?
  17. JamesL

    Portsmouth Vs Derby

    Hard to tell on highlights but it looks like he gets to 1 and blows the whistle not accounting for the final second having to elapse. I don't think it would have changed the outcome though. The goalkeeper hasn't helped himself. There was no reason to fall to the ground. Count started correctly...
  18. JamesL

    IFAB Q & A question

    No. The manager can't issue a caution. Only the referee can.
  19. JamesL

    PAL v LEE

    I had a closely related issue in a game in probably my 3rd or 4th match as a level 4. I did the same team twice in very close proximity, away both matches and there were two players who looked similar ish and both happend to get cautioned in both games. What is did was showed a yellow card...
  20. JamesL

    PAL v LEE

    No doubt the palace players helped the team realise there was an issue. I think a leeds player cottoned on too and told the carded player to go away quietly before he realised he was on a caution already
Back
Top