Search results

His hand moves towards the ball. That’s deliberate handling. No need to consider distance, deflections etc, leave that stuff for unnaturally bigger.

In most cases, we would struggle to justify a red card for endangering the safety or excessive force for a hair pull. If we want to justify a red card for hair pulling, which I think we do (definitely not biased by my long hair), we need to fall back on brutality, an act which is “savage...

Football also expects that an IDFK is awarded when a goalkeeper handles the ball inside their own penalty area after attempting to kick the ball to release it into play after a teammate has deliberately passed it to them. Edit to add that football also expects the goalkeeper to be sent off for...

If I’m understanding the article correctly, a team official was cautioned for delaying the restart of play by the opposing team? I’m certainly hoping not cause even I know that’s wrong in Law. And he also deliberately threw or kicked an object onto the field of play which is also a sending-off...

Yeah, hammered on. Well done.

I know a referee coach whose advice for determining sanction is “Give a red card if it makes you go ouch”. Studs to the Achilles with a moderate degree of force clearly endangers the safety of the opponent. Exacerbated by the fact the player is very late and has no chance to fairly play the...

I eliminated the goalkeeper as he committed the offence. No guidance I’ve come across clarifies that the general rule that the player that commits an offence isn’t considered for the purposes of DOGSO. (This doesn’t mean such instruction doesn’t exist though.)

Based purely on the one angle linked, clear DOGSO for me. If the keeper’s not there, the attacker is gaining possession of the ball in the middle of the field near the edge of the penalty area, facing goal, with no defenders between him and the goal.

My first instinct for the Wolves challenge was red but after consideration, I prefer yellow as the point of contact is the top of the boot where the opponent is well-protected. However, I appreciate that the nature of the challenge is very concerning. Red is probably the easier sell at lower...

Excessive force is when a player exceeds the necessary level of force. Brutality is an act which is savage, ruthless or deliberately violent. The necessary amount of force to be used when the ball is not in play is negligible. Kicking an opponent definitely exceeds that. Deliberately kicking...

Football expects, and referees have generally given, an offside when a player ducks out of the way of a ball that is heading towards goal. Is this inconsistent with how the Law is actually written? Absolutely, but that’s well above my paygrade.

On instances where the flag is delayed, ARs aren’t delaying the flag because they’re not sure, they’re delaying the flag because they’ve been told to so that VAR can intervene if they’ve got the decisions wrong. I know this is controversial guidance but ARs on the Premier League obviously need...

*unless it’s a ceremonial free kick. But yeah, Law 13.3 makes this pretty clear; “If, when a free kick is taken, an opponent is closer to the ball than the required distance, the kick is retaken unless the advantage can be applied; but if a player takes a free kick quickly and an opponent who...

Drink some radioactive goop in the hope you grow eyes in the back of your head? In all honesty, as long as you’re looking in the area where there is most likely to be a serious incident, not much else you can do.

https://www.bbc.com/sport/football/articles/cdjrgl4j3g2o

Defender’s made a sliding challenge, he’s missed the ball and he’s clipped the attacker. This seems like a clear-cut penalty unless I’m missing something.

sigh

I might not have technically delayed the restart but your match control is shot if you don’t caution that.

Yeah, I definitely got the no call wrong lol. Still not convinced about reckless though (low intensity).

I’d be curious to hear others’ thoughts on this but I’m not giving a penalty. Since the defender is attempting to play the ball, his momentum carries him into the attacker and he’s only putting his hands out to protect himself, I don’t think this meets the relatively high threshold for awarding...