Search results

I get that they’re “managing an event” as much as officiating a football game but somebody needs to be brave and caution him for it, and if he continues then give him a second caution. It’s the most blatant example there is of “clearly/persistently not respecting the confines of their own team’s...

It’s a clear foul and yellow card for me. Take a pick of SPA or reckless. I don’t see it as endangering safety, and the Rangers defender is close enough to provide cover so not DOGO. I do however think you should have had a penalty for the shirt pull on David Watson.

Poor decision for the referee to give it in the first instance but sometimes our eyes deceive us and we think we saw something that didn’t actually happen. So I do have some sympathy - we’re all human after all and mistakes happen. Not really sure what the VAR is thinking though. I can’t see...

I think this thread has been skewed by the predominantly English membership of this forum, and the reluctance to allow comms in England. Up here in Scotland their use is much more widespread and it's a common site even for grassroots finals now to see the three officials micd up. Many of the...

Thanks everyone for the responses. Not a simple decision obviously, so always happy to back the onfield officials in their call.

I'll post the highlights clip when they're uploaded to Youtube later on, but hopefully I can describe the incident sufficiently. The ball was rolling back towards the goalkeeper, who is deemed to have picked it up outside his area. The replays aren't 100% conclusive, so I'm happy to go with the...

This is the kind of line that Dermot Gallagher pedals that is actually complete nonsense. Handball interpretation in Scotland is far closer to England than Europe. Two or three seasons ago it was definitely a lot more strict/bonkers, but they’ve definitely toned it down and are generally a lot...

The middle one would very much depend on tone and context of the game up to that point. The other two don’t insinuate violence at all for me so I’ve no issue with them. (And well done for the handling of the initial comment in the OP)

As long as you’re clear in your communication then I think it’s a fairly easy sell. First offence is obstructing the keeper, so that’s the restart regardless of what happens after that. As @Russell Jones says, a yellow for the attacker can help sell it. From personal experience last season I...

I think they were stuck between a rock and a hard place. Replace the VAR and it’s seen as an admission of error, but equally Michael Salisbury will have seen the fall out from the game and it would have undoubtedly been on his mind, even just subconsciously, if he was still involved in the game...

Could the weather come into it a bit as well? The amount of rain that had fallen during the second half made it noticeably more difficult to make a controlled movement at times.

Not sure it’s a handball or a caution for me. Even if you do deem it handball I’m still not sure what the caution would be for.

Tarkowski moves his body towards the ball because he is a defender who wants to block the shot. In doing so, his arm is by his side in a natural position. In my mind the “moving the hand towards the ball” justification is for situations like the Liverpool v Bournemouth game where the hand...

Real time I thought it was handball so I do have sympathy with the onfield officials. Not really sure what justification VAR has though as after only one replay it was clear it was a natural position.

I asked my sister about that because it had crossed my mind previously. She said it’s a natural instinct in the same way as putting your hands across your face if a ball is fired at it from close distance. So no handball is the sensible call IMO.

LotG define holding as “impacting the opponents movement” which this did. Nothing about the impact on play. I know where you’re coming from, but I think this is more England being out of line with everywhere else, in allowing rugby tackle-esque holding in the penalty area.

I’m unsure on the first Italian red - he gives a second yellow for it but the TV replays aren’t very conclusive so I’ll give him the benefit of the doubt on that as he gets one look in real time. First yellow was a fairly standard caution so no complaints there. I was absolutely delighted to see...

If the opposition are winning 1-0 though, then the goalkeeper is less likely to be wasting time surely and will want to be releasing the ball back into play quickly? And if they’re obstructed from doing that by an opponent then we give the foul, as we would currently.

Pre-season? I’m not finished the current season yet :)

I’ve never stopped a corner to give a warning. I’ll often give a verbal “I’m watching - nothing stupid” or something along those lines but if continues then I’ll give the free kick/penalty as appropriate. A lot of things annoy me in professional games, but top of my list of things that do my...