Search results

Who said it needed to be willing?

My interest isn't in the specific scenario. I haven't seen video that isn't geoblocked. My interest is in the way we're framing it. It's been suggested that, before downgrading to yellow, we should have confidence that the keeper will save it. Actually, before upgrading to red, it should be...

My view is the lack of control - having already taken the shot - is what withdraws this from being an 'opportunity'. The attacker can do nothing to improve the chances of the ball going in. It's either an obvious goal or it's not. Thinking on DOGSO lines is erroneous, in my humble view

For those advocating DOGSO-H, which of the mandatory considerations were met?

Open goal seals it for me

I'm steering away from red because blue has largely stopped his momentum and, to a large extent, the impact is because yellow is kicking through into the blue leg. I don't see that his safety is endangered. However, without doubt reckless from the moment blue lunges to clear the ball away

It's astounding that the players think they can hinder the police in arresting the fat mess just because they are still in a football pitch! How ridiculous is our sport sometimes

Bless them

The only one's I'm really sharp on, and will tend to simply award the throw to the opposition, is when the thrower cynically throws the ball from many many metres towards their own goal from the correct location in order to take the ball uncontested. Most other times, if the location is a...

I must say, I'm minded to just stick to the Laws. All if the videos are dependant on their circumstances and the written clarification is less than helpful, in my view. It's much easier to point to the LOTG and glossary than to some vague circular

I think the IFAB might need to have a think whether deliberate still means deliberate. They were pretty clear in saying that the law needed no amendment, oy clarification, but a number of these 'not deliberate' videos look pretty bloody deliberate to me!

Short-long----short for me but, then, I'm a maverick.

They seem to come with nicer legs than I've got. I have last year's shorts and they're very comfy. These look to have a more pronounced back pocket

Regardless if whether vio by conduct or not, this is smack bang within the recently extended OFFINABUS

Blue is also defending. There's an expectation that fouls are a bit softer when it comes to the defending side. That being said, not sure I'm blowing that. Depends on the angle.

Here's a question.... What happens if, at 2-1, the officials run off, blow FT and then while the officials are bolting for the sheds, fans are flooding the pitch, and VAR says 'I recommend an onfield review for a penalty'. Seems problematic.

He was too apologetic and it was too funny. I couldn't stay mad. Believe me, I tried.

I had one on the weekend - striker beats defender who, when striker is 8 yards from goal, screams at him. Striker fluffs kick and GK collects the scraps. Whistle, IFK, yellow. All accepted with little question. Couldn't bring myself to DOGSO as the striker seemed to be off balance anyway.

Yeh, I think we can limit our disagreement to seeing this particular event differently.

@Murri O But for @one 's helpful still (which seems to indicate this should be a FK to the keeper), I'd go penalty on this one Assuming he is not in control and he has merely patted the ball away, careless charge regardless of whether he's tipped the ball away or not. Could have avoided the...