The Ref Stop

Dissent Tolerance Level

Donate to RefChat

Help keep RefChat running, any donation would be appreciated

Joserra

New Member
Hi fellow refs.

I am a Level 5 referee in the South East of England. I was reffing a Grassroot football game this afternoon for my local FA.

After the ball had gone out of play a defender close to me was complaining about what he claimed as a foul that I had not given just instances before.
As I was close to him, 2m or so, I turn around to talk to him, and he shouted at me directly at my face, "You are ****!" Loud enough for the players close to us to hear it.

I would like to ascertain your opinion:

1. Red Card
2. Sin Bin
3. Nothing/Bollecking

Thanks
 
The Ref Stop
Might depend on what is in the *****! But the “you are” in front of it gets me thinking about red. (Of course, in the WC it’s probably nothing, but that’s not what we’re talking about . . . )
 
You've always got law to fall back on, but everyone has their own tolerance and looking at how the game has gone, is going etc, it's a bet minimum caution with a stern bollocking for me to make sure other participants know it isn't acceptable.
 
We can't see starred out words but context and delibery matters. A frustrated player venting, yellow card sin bin, said aggressively, confrontational, we could get to red.
 
Last edited:
Context is king. While the OP gives a little context, what I'd do depends a lot on context. Gathering context starts even before the game starts. It could go from an unlikely no sanction and a witty response. To also an unlikely red card with not much of verbal response.

Assuming the censored asterisk is the word sh!t, in most contexts I look past the dictionary meaning of the word used in this instance and look at the contextual meaning of it, keeping in mind use of the specific word can mean some degree of intent to insult.
 
Last edited:
I’m with @JamesL and @Pembroke - assuming it’s not screamed aggressively in my face and it’s the S word not the C word, YC sin bin for me.

If it was youth football then I generally have a lower tolerance - at U13 to U14 it would be RC regardless, at U15-16 it’s more context based, and as I treat U18s much the same as OA it would be as described originally.
 
Thank you so much for your feedback. The word in asterisks is s-h-i-t, not sure why the asterisks. I had written down the actual word.

I went for red, as he told me looking directly at me and at short distance, and very vehemently.

One of my best referee colleagues reffing in the same league said that I had been a bit too harsh, that it would have been a sin bin for him.

Hence, I would like to get your opinions. I'm not new to this, I have been doing it well over 30 years. But I was wondering if I had been too strict.

Loads of good points in your replies. Every day is school day!!
 
Thank you so much for your feedback. The word in asterisks is s-h-i-t, not sure why the asterisks. I had written down the actual word.

I went for red, as he told me looking directly at me and at short distance, and very vehemently.

One of my best referee colleagues reffing in the same league said that I had been a bit too harsh, that it would have been a sin bin for him.

Hence, I would like to get your opinions. I'm not new to this, I have been doing it well over 30 years. But I was wondering if I had been too strict.

Loads of good points in your replies. Every day is school day!!
He made it personal by adding "You're . . ." which makes the red card the favoured option for me.
 
I’m with @JamesL and @Pembroke - assuming it’s not screamed aggressively in my face and it’s the S word not the C word, YC sin bin for me.

If it was youth football then I generally have a lower tolerance - at U13 to U14 it would be RC regardless, at U15-16 it’s more context based, and as I treat U18s much the same as OA it would be as described originally.
Yes, in youth football I would expect more respects from the boys/girls.

The player did said it just a couple of metres off my face. He certainly meant it!! He was quite frustrated coz I hadn't given a free kick one minute earlier
 
Would you expect to get away with shouting that directly at a player?
Is it an insult?
It's not public disagreement with a match official's decision so how can it be deemed dissent?
Red all day long.
 
Thank you so much for your feedback. The word in asterisks is s-h-i-t, not sure why the asterisks. I had written down the actual word.

I went for red, as he told me looking directly at me and at short distance, and very vehemently.

One of my best referee colleagues reffing in the same league said that I had been a bit too harsh, that it would have been a sin bin for him.

Hence, I would like to get your opinions. I'm not new to this, I have been doing it well over 30 years. But I was wondering if I had been too strict.

Loads of good points in your replies. Every day is school day!!
Well done you did the right thing for abuse in your face. Your colleague and those like him are letting the side down unfortunately.
 
Yes, in youth football I would expect more respects from the boys/girls.

The player did said it just a couple of metres off my face. He certainly meant it!! He was quite frustrated coz I hadn't given a free kick one minute earlier
I certainly think RC is justified. Player only had himself to blame.
 
Back
Top