The Ref Stop

Leeds v Spurs

Donate to RefChat

Help keep RefChat running, any donation would be appreciated

Paul_10

RefChat Addict
Couple of controversial calls in that first half with a potential handball and red card with neither given.

I think the handball decision is correct and even more so when TNT showed that angle which apparently the VAR does not have access too as it clearly comes off the shoulder yet the angle the VAR had looked way more 50/50.

The second incident with Bogle with a challenge down Tel's Achilles area. You see this is the annoyance I do have with the VAR because the ref did not even showed a yellow card which seems to suggest to me the ref did not see the contact Bogle left foot made and from John Brooks angle it just looked like a careless foul so surely this could go down as a potential missed incident and you can send the ref to the review area because it ticks the boxes for a red card. I think the VAR looked way too long at it and it seems the doubts may of came from that there was some contact on the achilles but then more contact seems to be on Tel's ankle/boot. I'll understand a bit more on a non intervention if the ref showed a yellow card and he saw the contact from Bogle's left foot on Tel but I'm not convinced he seen that contact.
 
The Ref Stop
From this view I'd be very surprised if part of the ball isn't striking his arm below the 'arm pit line'

The second one suggests top marginal to call. On field decision either way
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20261107-135756.png
    Screenshot_20261107-135756.png
    564.9 KB · Views: 8
  • Screenshot_20261107-140543.png
    Screenshot_20261107-140543.png
    757.9 KB · Views: 7
Last edited:
From this view I'd be very surprised if part of the ball isn't striking his arm below the 'arm pit line'

The second one suggests top marginal to call. On field decision either way
There's a good reverse angle, ball deffo comes off the shoulder
 
There's a good reverse angle, ball deffo comes off the shoulder
Yeah, the angle from behind him very clearly shows it came off his shoulder.

For Bogle's potential red card, I'm pretty sure they only took that long as Tel was down having treatment for the duration of the check, obviously can't restart whilst that is ongoing so it gave them time to check it without being under time pressure. I'm pretty sure without the injury they'd have checked and cleared it much quicker.

The commentary team really didn't help here, Darren Fletcher showed a total lack of understanding of how VAR works. I don't know if he is actually that ignorant of the laws or just wanted to be controversial, but despite not thinking it was a red card he repeatedly said the referee should be sent to the screen to "make the decision for himself". Clearly that isn't how it works. Then he compared it to the Mateta red card last week, that was totally different as it was a lunge from distance, this was someone treading on an opponent with much less force. They even then showed that incident to try to discredit today's decision.

They then spent at least the next 15 minutes bemoaning the lack of a caution for it, repeatedly saying it had caused John Brooks to lose control, which he very definitely hadn't. And to make matters worse for the potential handball he incorrectly claimed the angle that showed it definitely hit the shoulder wasn't available to VAR, which is utter rubbish. Just because the TV director took an age to show it doesn't mean it wasn't available to VAR, they would have checked that decision from every available angle. They also claimed that Pedro Porro should definitely have had a second yellow card, yet the player he fouled was moving towards the corner flag so it couldn't possibly be SPA and was just a simple careless challenge.

Was just a prolonged period of referee bashing and really was pathetic. People will watch that and think his totally uneducated comments and opinions were correct.
 
I agree about the Darren Fletcher comments, it's not just refereeing decisions it's decisions of players and be quite critical of players at times, surely that is more of the job of the co commentator.

That said, i do think the VAR should of intervened here, surely John Brooks has not seen that contact and think it's just a careless foul. As with the Liverpool Arsenal incident, I'm sure it's under VAR protocol a review can be called if a referee has potentially missed something and this tackle certainly ticks all the boxes of a red card. Plus we got the consistency argument, anytime you see contact with studs on the achilles then its a red card most of the time and I think this one is as bad if not perhaps worse than the Mateta one last week. I can't help but feel the refs call(as pro ref wants it's VAR to make their judgment on) of just a careless foul is a clear and obvious error yet you could justify not intervening if he saw it as reckless if you don't want to go down the re refereeing route.
 
. I can't help but feel the refs call(as pro ref wants it's VAR to make their judgment on) of just a careless foul is a clear and obvious error yet you could justify not intervening if he saw it as reckless if you don't want to go down the re refereeing route.
if it’s ok not to send down if cautioned, it’s ok to not send down. It doesn’t matter if it was a clear error to only call the foul. It has to be a clear error not to have gone red.
 
I support that its not a clear error. But it really should be seen as a red. Studs to the Achilles is a lot more dangerous than most studs to the shin tackles.
 
if it’s ok not to send down if cautioned, it’s ok to not send down. It doesn’t matter if it was a clear error to only call the foul. It has to be a clear error not to have gone red.

I'm only basing that on Pro Ref's way of how they deal with these things with "referees call". Ive never liked it as I think it can make the VAR's job much harder than it already is and we shouldn't be going down the route that a VAR intervention is re refereeing when the ref ultimately has the final say. For me this ticks the boxes for SFP and even if the ref saw it as reckless he should be sent to the screen.

 
Back
Top