A&H

Sin binning a player due to CAR dissent

Jed

Jed

Member
This question may sound stupid but from the “England football” website I could only see it mention “dissent towards the referee” not assistants and it didn’t mention the word “match officials”. I’ve never had to think about booking or sin binning a player for dissent toward a CAR but my question is can dissent still be shown towards a assistant and be sanctioned with a sin bin even if it’s a CAR
 
A&H International
Dissent =

"Public protest or disagreement (verbal and/or physical) with a match official’s decision; punishable by a caution (yellow card)"

A Club assistant referee is, in my opinion, a match official in that game and so dissent towards them is punishable by a caution. In England, below step 5 and below, all dissent cautions for players results in a temporary dismissal (unless the match has ended).
 
Last edited:
JamesL said:
Dissent =

"Public protest or disagreement (verbal and/or physical) with a match official’s decision; punishable by a caution (yellow card)"

A Club assistant referee is, in my opinion, a match official in that game and so dissent towards them is punishable by a caution. In England, below step 5, all dissent cautions for players results in a temporary dismissal (unless the match has ended).
Click to expand...
Cheers, I should have checked ifab instead of looking at England football website but am rushed off my feet at the moment, but to be fair I did also wanna hear others opinions around the CAR situation. Appreciate the response James
 
Only tangentially relevant, but a point of note that a CAR isn’t making any decision, but assisting the Referee who is then making one. So it’s dissent towards to you by proxy 😂
 
I sent off a player for swearing at a CAR, so I'd be happy with dissent sin bin.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jed
Viridis1886 said:
I sent off a player for swearing at a CAR, so I'd be happy with dissent sin bin.
Click to expand...
Should probably make the distinction here to urge caution linking the 2 offences in this way.

Dissent can only be committed against a match official.

offinabus only need a participant to have used offensive, insulting or abusive language/gestures.
 
Reckon I'd be more likely to act on dissent against my CAR than I would when aimed at yours truly
Indeed, I C2'd a player for exactly that in one of only two games I reff'd with CARs season just gone
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jed
I think there is a lot of context to this also, if it is some old boy running the line and they are running the line well and fair versus the fullback who has just been subbed off and is continuing his on field shenanigans with the winger from the CAR role.

I have had a CAR shout me over and tell me the winger was swearing at him and to offer him some protection (funny enough he was playing fullback against that very winger 2 minutes prior). So I quickly explained this to him and told him for us to continue I will need to swap him.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top