JamesL's latest activity
-
JamesL replied to the thread Observation report.There should be an appeals process so as a starter for 10 I would be asking them what that process is -
JamesL replied to the thread Observation report.Appeals are generally only allowed where the written text is wrong in law or the mark awarded does not match the written text. I think...
-
JamesL replied to the thread Short Sleeve FA Match Official Kit.Yours if you want to buy it. Drop me a personal message and will take it down off eBay 👍
-
JamesL replied to the thread Short Sleeve FA Match Official Kit.Just to say I do still have the shirt. Feel bad now folks are handing out for free (thanks @Runner-Ref 🤪) so will try my luck...
-
There are no timed examples, it is just a very generic comment. If it was a 6.5 I might let it go, but for a 6.0 it is very lazy...
-
JamesL replied to the thread Newcastle Vs Arsenal.I disagree. As does the independent panel who unanimously cleared all 3 decisions on this one (which includes the PGMO rep). It is not...
-
JamesL replied to the thread Observation report.I think I would. It's clearly the wrong mark awarded..it seems he has said more than 1 on the basis there was more than one "soft foul"...
-
I would have prefered ”foul tolerance” etc
-
JamesL replied to the thread Observation report.Everyone just casually over looking the fact it says more than 1 major development. We can argue all day as to whether the comment...
-
JamesL replied to the thread The one that got away..I agree. It's a retake of original free kick. If the ball is in play then it's hard to say the kicker was distracted by the shout..
-
I don’t see how it can possibly be downgraded. Law 12 specifically exempt holding and pulling from possible downgrade to yellow. Only...
-
Of course! I think you're wrong but hey ho 😅
-
JamesL replied to the thread Celtic v Aberdeen.Happy with foul. I can stretch to acceptance either side of that i.e. no foul or foul and caution if the referee gives the right...
-
JamesL replied to the thread Chelsea v Man City.There is just something inherently wrong with giving managers a button to say you've got that wrong and then the R looks again and has...
-
JamesL replied to the thread City of Liverpool vs Chasetown.Got to make up for the poor positioning, somehow 😏
