The Ref Stop

es1's latest activity

  • E
    es1 replied to the thread Bristol City v Wrexham.
    i can agree that i think it should be offside (if the laws were rewritten) the defender plays the ball because of the presence of the...
  • E
    es1 replied to the thread Bristol City v Wrexham.
    don't think this is that controversial, goal is correct in law
  • E
    es1 replied to the thread Aston Villa v Newcastle.
    penalty goal makes a lot of sense genuinely very few scenarios where it would be enacted (and you'd need some very prescriptive...
  • E
    es1 reacted to DavidObs's post in the thread Aston Villa v Newcastle with Like Like.
    I would go along with that. Whilst IFAB attempted to learn things from rugby, they were the wrong things. Moving play forward 10 yards...
  • E
    es1 replied to the thread Aston Villa v Newcastle.
    Potentially, but definitely lots we can learn from field hockey imo (restarts/sin bins in particular)
  • E
    es1 replied to the thread Aston Villa v Newcastle.
    works in hockey (field and ice)
  • E
    es1 reacted to Big Cat's post in the thread Aston Villa v Newcastle with Like Like.
    We've had it a long time now. Notwithstanding the factual stuff, like offside (I think that's a separate debate).... I'd argue the...
  • E
    es1 reacted to one's post in the thread Aston Villa v Newcastle with Wow Wow.
    You ain't seen nothing yet. AI is coming.
  • E
    es1 reacted to bester's post in the thread Aston Villa v Newcastle with Like Like.
    Dump it and come back in a few years when the technology is sorted. That's what they did in NFL. Factual decisions. Offside position...
  • E
    es1 replied to the thread Aston Villa v Newcastle.
    We (royal we) have turned refereeing at the top level into a science - it cannot be refereed robotically. Every stakeholder within the...
  • E
    es1 replied to the thread Aston Villa v Newcastle.
    in an excellent (elevated) position in the stadium i thought it was off live. hard decision? medium i'd say - would expect a top AR to...
  • E
    es1 reacted to one's post in the thread Birmingham City v WBA with Like Like.
    Good suggestion but needs some work. Put all defenders, including the goalkeeper clearly outside that triangle and it would be...
  • E
    es1 reacted to bloovee's post in the thread Man City v Fulham - Hair Pulling with Haha Haha.
    I think the official PGMOL explanation would be "only glancing contact"...
  • E
    es1 replied to the thread Man City v Fulham - Hair Pulling.
    Just seen the foden 'tackle' How in the world isn't that a red? Shocker all round
  • E
    es1 replied to the thread Tottenham v Newcastle.
    no no, i want it for everything, regardless of outcome (red/yellow/penalty etc)
Show older items
Back
Top