Ciley Myrus
RefChat Addict
Kuipers in middle, with Scotland represented as 4th
More important, AR2 ran my line for a week back in 2002
More important, AR2 ran my line for a week back in 2002
Peter Walton declared the HB as a penalty kick on the basis that IFAB indicated as such back in June
No accounting for the fact that those Law changes are yet to come into effect
Think it's in line with current UEFA instructions, which were the basis for the United penalty against PSG. I think UEFA's current instructions/interpretation is where the IFAB changes are heading in June.Peter Walton declared the HB as a penalty kick on the basis that IFAB indicated as such back in June
No accounting for the fact that those Law changes are yet to come into effect
Not necessarily disagreeing with the decision, just the expert justification
On that subject, am i right in saying that the Law regarding continuation of holding into the PA, does not extend to foul tackles (which we would award based on first point-of-contact or even maximal contact?Could've easily been a VAR HV against TAA in *other game*
What about the Sterling foul on Son, did it continue inside the box?
This is the thing that gets on my nerves. Current instruction should be based on current LawsThink it's in line with current UEFA instructions,
On that subject, am i right in saying that the Law regarding continuation of holding into the PA, does not extend to foul tackles (which we would award based on first point-of-contact or even maximal contact?
Any ideas on the Yellow Card?This is getting to be a bit of a joke now, games are being decided on a total lottery. I really don't see what Danny Rose could do differently there, he's dived to block the ball and your arms will always come out. Then as the ball comes towards him his arm is actually coming back towards his body yet he is still penalised. Yet in the other game the ball was travelling much slower, Alexander Arnold does nothing to get his arm out of the way and isn't penalised despite a VAR review.
The people coming up with these interpretations have clearly never kicked a ball in their life. I've said it before, but you don't run around playing football like a penguin with your arms pinned by your side.
Any ideas on the Yellow Card?
Next season, it will be a penalty... this season...NO.
This is what is annoying me with handball. For me, under the current laws, that is not a penalty. He does not deliberately play the ball with his arm and the distance is minimal. And then you have Peter Walton telling people it is correct because UEFA said they would give it. Ok, but are we saying that the UEFA guidance then is not the same as the LOTG? Next season, it will be a penalty... this season...NO.