A&H
GraemeS

GraemeS

Level 5 Referee
RefChat Addict
Joined
Last seen
Messages
5,167
Reaction score
4,105
Points
498

Latest activity Postings About

    • GraemeS
      GraemeS reacted to Runner Ref's post in the thread goalkeeper sent off for handball - dogso? with Like Like.
      I completely agree with your first sentence. We had a debate about 6 months ago on here around a couple of appeals that were successful...
    • GraemeS
      GraemeS replied to the thread VAR announcing decisions.
      I mean yeah, exactly that.
    • GraemeS
      GraemeS reacted to Runner Ref's post in the thread goalkeeper sent off for handball - dogso? with Like Like.
      Does bring me back to my earlier point. Many people claimed the game expects a red card- no one has been able to explain who or why the...
    • GraemeS
      GraemeS replied to the thread VAR announcing decisions.
      I think more than anything else, like the live audio, they worry about the explanation being poor or incorrect in law. And the fact I...
    • GraemeS
      GraemeS replied to the thread VAR announcing decisions.
      It adds literally nothing when compared to the graphic that gets put on the screen. "Serious Foul Play" doesn't tell you what actually...
    • GraemeS
      GraemeS replied to the thread WHM v LIV.
      There are three separate gestures - a one-armed Advantage signal - that arguably could be pointing for a foul if you imagine a whistle...
    • GraemeS
      GraemeS reacted to DJIC's post in the thread WHM v LIV with Like Like.
      As an ex-grass roots GK, I was intrigued by Demot Gallagher's opinion, kept repeating AT's mistake/mess but my view is the GK has made...
    • GraemeS
      GraemeS replied to the thread WHM v LIV.
      I think that's arguably defensible and does open up an interesting discussion around if a player not realising they have an advantage...
    • GraemeS
      GraemeS replied to the thread WHM v LIV.
      Right. If something that didn't happen had instead happened, that might have been an appropriate response. Irrelevant, but yeah, I can't...
    • GraemeS
      GraemeS replied to the thread WHM v LIV.
      But that's an insane standard of proof? I'm not a doctor - and if I was, and could put Areola into a brilliantly equipped surgery, and...
    • GraemeS
      GraemeS reacted to Peter Grove's post in the thread WHM v LIV with Like Like.
      Because he realised that to justify his actions, he needed to make it look like the keeper was injured, when it was clear from his...
    • GraemeS
      GraemeS replied to the thread WHM v LIV.
      We never know for sure any player might not have a little knock. That doesn't mean we randomly stop the game seconds before a player is...
    • GraemeS
      GraemeS replied to the thread WHM v LIV.
      In a hypothetical world, you're guessing I will have a different response? Sure, that's a useful addition to the discussion :rolleyes:
    • GraemeS
      GraemeS replied to the thread WHM v LIV.
      After already assessing from nearby and then waving to play on? He then jogs another 20 yards, turns round and only then blows the...
    • GraemeS
      GraemeS replied to the thread WHM v LIV.
      No. I'm dismissive of opinions that are based on nonsense and are attempting to drag the conversation off topic. Note that you're not...
    Show older items
  • Loading…
  • Loading…
Back
Top