City Red Card

[Josh]

Penalty?

 

[frank_ref]

Outside the box for me. The officials must have had some doubt, in which case you'd think they'd be erring on the side of caution. Or maybe not.

On a related note: Navas stays on his feet I reckon he blocks the clearance/pass.

 

[Matt Redmond]

dam voted wrong, option c

 

[frank_ref]

Hm. When I voted Option C it was 4 for A and none for anything else. But like my old ma always used to say, copying be the sincerest form of flattery.

 

[rainertheref]

Voted wrong option too -should have been No Penalty, Red Card. But only because I haven't seen this in context so I'm assuming there are no defenders who could possibly have got to him.

And clearly the initial contact is outside the box.

 

[Matthew]

I'm surprised by the disagreement on this, no arguments with the red card but the foul was quite clearly outside the box.