NEW SIN BINS
- Thread starter wa209
- Start date
System B. Pretty sure it was covered in the initial roll out but even if not that's inferred by the fact we only use it for dissent and the difference is all offences or some specific offences or singular offence.
Who is using system A them?
Under System B can a player shown two SEPERATE sin bin yellows be replaced after 10 minutes or is that dead now?
No idea, don't think there is a list published, but it certainly isn't in use in England
I "unofficially" did this before. Much easier to administer than allowing someone on while your "chasing" play.. Its the system A or system B that could cause confusion depending on what the leagues choose. You could find yourself on different leagues following a different format.
ChasObserverRefDeveloper
Regular Contributor
Only System B (sin bin only for dissent) is allowed in England.I "unofficially" did this before. Much easier to administer than allowing someone on while your "chasing" play.. Its the system A or system B that could cause confusion depending on what the leagues choose. You could find yourself on different leagues following a different format.
Peter Grove
RefChat Addict
I think you'd have to look up the information for every National Association in the world to find that out.
I reckon there are people on this forum that would see that as time well spent!
They work the same as any other yellow card, just with a 10 minute sin bin to go with it if the first one is for dissent.
Kes
I'll Decide ...
We had an interesting one Tuesday night where a substitute was cautioned for dissent. Standard caution as per the (English FA) sin bin rules. However, he came on as a sub about 4 minutes later. The question was raised, and it felt like… oh yeah, it feels somehow wrong.
Surely he can’t come on until his 10mins is served?
He can, because a caution to a non-playing participant is just a caution, there is no sin bin.
Before cards could be shown to managers and coaches it was a minefield in a similar way. A player manager could be sent from the dugout but could still come on as a sub depending what they had been removed for.
I stand corrected.