A&H

Studs up and a push in the back - A League

Murri O

Murri O

Well-Known Member
If this isn't geoblocked could some here offer an opinion on the 2 incidents shown. Ignore Bosnich's self proclaimed 'I'm an expert' carry on. (We're short on good football commentators here.)

https://theworldgame.sbs.com.au/vid...WoLCctl0ztgC_PIUJvMJN3PhkNx_bHDuO2ISyuoEXHJsE

For me the studs up tackle is at least a yellow if not a red and the push in the box, from behind with an arm, is a penalty. Wondering if the penalty is given then a red should follow for a DOGSO?

(Alternate link here to pen call. https://www.foxsports.com.au/video/football/a-league/expert-bozza-puts-foot-down!781105 )
and (studs up challenge here https://www.foxsports.com.au/video/football/a-league/should-duke-have-been-sent!781045 )
 
Last edited:
The Referee Store
Red card for the sliding challenge any day of the week.

Not 100% sure I'd be giving the pen, i can see why, but depending on the angle i can think the contact could look less than it is. If i did give it, RC for DOGSO.
 
The tackle warrants a red - no doubt.

The push in the back is a penalty too, followed by a red for the defender's deliberate nature in the challenge.
 
Res for the tackle and a red and penalty for the push.

If a player commits a dogso offence through pushing or pulling an opponent it has to be a red card.
 
Both are somewhere in the middle and different referees make different decisions. No matter what decision made, VAR should stay it of it.

Tackle is yellow for me. I would have given red if he was off the ground.

Push a penalty DOGSO. Defenders should know not to force the ref into a decision like that. He got lucky there.
 
one said:
Both are somewhere in the middle and different referees make different decisions. No matter what decision made, VAR should stay it of it.

Tackle is yellow for me. I would have given red if he was off the ground.

Push a penalty DOGSO. Defenders should know not to force the ref into a decision like that. He got lucky there.
Click to expand...
Take a very closer look at the tackle again and really analyze it and see if u come up with the same YC judgement
 
one said:
Yeap. I analysed it before and it was yellow. I really analysed it now and it's still yellow. Should I really really analyse it to see if I change my mind ? :)
Click to expand...
Okay if u said u did all that and still remains yellow den, yellow it is.. cheers
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top