Tim Punter's latest activity
-
Tim Punter replied to the thread Newcastle Vs West Ham.The first half was littered with players holding their heads after minimal contact with Guimarães and Paquetá being the worst offenders... -
An incident in this one that sums up the lengths teams will go to these days to get a tactical advantage. Around 12 minutes into the...
-
Tim Punter replied to the thread Bending down to head the ball.Thanks for the reply, really appreciate, as this is pretty much what I did. Was in a decent position and didn't see contact, so goal stood.
-
The decision is situational based. Assuming we all agree that the defender has put himself in a dangerous situation. Three feasible...
-
Tim Punter replied to the thread Bending down to head the ball.That is fantastic advice, as next season may be my first one with scored observations, so already worrying about missing things like this!
-
Tim Punter reacted to RefereeX's post in the thread Liv City - Klopp and Pep for maybe the last time with
Like.
In my first season as a level 7 I remember turning down an appeal for a clear high foot by a defender inside the penalty area because my... -
Tim Punter reacted to RefereeX's post in the thread Liv City - Klopp and Pep for maybe the last time with Like.
Looks like I'm controversial in my opinion here, but I really don't think that's a foul at the end. MacAllister initiates the contact...
-
Tim Punter replied to the thread Bending down to head the ball.I was joking about disallowing the goal, as I would clearly play the advantage. I am still a bit unclear about why the defender could...
-
If you deem the defender to have committed an offence then obviously you can apply advantage and award the goal, providing you haven't...
-
Tim Punter replied to the thread Bending down to head the ball.That would have caused a proper uproar. Disallow the goal and give and ifk to the attacking team instead. In one fail swoop annoys both...
-
I do believe this is one of the hardest calls to sell in football sometimes.
-
For me the player that stooped to head the ball is endangering himself. I'd give an indirect free kick to the defending side.
-
Tim Punter reacted to santa sangria's post in the thread Liv City - Klopp and Pep for maybe the last time with Like.
Saw the highlights. Doku plays the ball very dangerously and his studs contact the chest and thigh of the opponent. I know no one wants...
-
Tim Punter reacted to YourBootsAreUntied's post in the thread Liv City - Klopp and Pep for maybe the last time with Like.
New here. I really enjoy the discussions and thanks for helping me be a better ref. It does seem like the pendulum has swung from the...
-
Tim Punter reacted to one's post in the thread Liv City - Klopp and Pep for maybe the last time with Like.
This. If it was given as a red card I don't think VAR would have overturned it. Not giving a foul altogether is surely a C&O error...