RefereeX's latest activity
-
RRefereeX replied to the thread Worth Appealing?.Having never actually appealed a report either, here is the limited amount I know. The mark can be reduced on appeal, so be wary of...
-
RRefereeX replied to the thread Everton - Forest.I don't disagree, but I think the argument will be that the VAR needs to have operated at that level of the game to fully understand it.
-
RRefereeX replied to the thread Everton - Forest.I think there will be in the future, but I think it will probably be reserved for those who've retired from refereeing top level matches...
-
RRefereeX replied to the thread Coventry - Man Utd.Having not actually seen the Wan-Bissaka handball, but taking your word for it that it is virtually the same as the Grealish incident, I...
-
RRefereeX replied to the thread Everton - Forest.Just to add further to the debate, had VAR given the 3rd as a penalty, what sanction are we expecting? I would think it would have to be...
-
RRefereeX replied to the thread Everton - Forest.With force? If you think there is anything more than minimal force in that first penalty shout then it's not even worth debating...
-
RRefereeX replied to the thread Everton - Forest.Back to the decisions themselves, the first penalty is one of them that if AT gives it it’s probably not overturned but it’s definitely...
-
RPoints deductions should come in here. In effect they have openly accused both the match officials and PGMOL of corruption, they cannot...
-
RRefereeX replied to the thread City vs Chelsea.Agree it wasn’t enough for a penalty, think it’s another one where if it had been given you’d perhaps not see it overturned either...
-
RCompletely agree, but on the same basis the observer shouldn't be putting something significant in the report that wasn't discussed in...
-
RRefereeX replied to the thread Fast tracking.At the end of the day, in all walks of life, you need to work hard and also have a little bit of luck. If you work hard enough, you can...
-
RRefereeX replied to the thread Interesting observation.Surely an observer should not be asking assistants what was covered in pre-match instructions though. The AR may not have been paying...
-
RNo, we won't close. 3 months is about the time limit for threads
-
RRefereeX replied to the thread Fast tracking.Firstly, that's not a 'fast track system' - that will presumably be FA CORE. It doesn't get you promoted without doing the required...
